Re: Regression Testing

2014-07-15 Thread John Hewson
ying thing about this scheme is >> that, after commiting the correction, the test runs again and reports a >> regression because it now compares to the faulty version of the rendering. >> >> Best regards, >> Petr. >> >> -Původní zpráva- From:

Re: Regression Testing

2014-07-14 Thread Tilman Hausherr
it now compares to the faulty version of the rendering. Best regards, Petr. -Původní zpráva- From: John Hewson Sent: Friday, July 04, 2014 7:39 PM To: dev@pdfbox.apache.org Subject: Re: Regression Testing Hi Tilman Thanks for your thoughts, I think that your concerns are already covered

Re: Regression Testing

2014-07-08 Thread John Hewson
Hi Tim, > My initial plan for TIKA-1302 is very similar to what Tilman outlined, and > my understanding/concerns/thoughts were very much in line with what he > articulated. The idea is that there should be a small Apache license-able > gold truth set like both projects now have for specific u

Re: Regression Testing

2014-07-08 Thread John Hewson
On 4 Jul 2014, at 14:05, Petr Slabý wrote: > Hi, > following is a description of what we are doing in our company. > > With our software, we run regression tests after each nightly build and > sometimes it is a tough fight. If there is a regression, it is not so easy to > find which commit ca

Re: Regression Testing

2014-07-08 Thread John Hewson
On 6 Jul 2014, at 01:28, Guillaume Bailleul wrote: > About "why are isartor test not done by default?" > > In the first time of preflight in PDFBox, I made it not "by default" > because some manipulation were needed to make it work, I was not good > with maven in these time. When I changed that

RE: Regression Testing

2014-07-07 Thread Allison, Timothy B.
aturday, July 05, 2014 5:01 PM To: dev@pdfbox.apache.org Subject: Re: Regression Testing On 5 Jul 2014, at 13:47, Tilman Hausherr wrote: > Am 05.07.2014 22:12, schrieb John Hewson: >>>>> Copyrights is a problem: I'm testing mostly with JIRA attachments that >>>&g

Re: Regression Testing

2014-07-07 Thread Petr Slabý
test runs again and reports a regression because it now compares to the faulty version of the rendering. Best regards, Petr. -Původní zpráva- From: John Hewson Sent: Friday, July 04, 2014 7:39 PM To: dev@pdfbox.apache.org Subject: Re: Regression Testing Hi Tilman Thanks for your th

Re: Regression Testing

2014-07-06 Thread Guillaume Bailleul
About "why are isartor test not done by default?" In the first time of preflight in PDFBox, I made it not "by default" because some manipulation were needed to make it work, I was not good with maven in these time. When I changed that using some download plugin of maven, I did not changed the defa

Re: Regression Testing

2014-07-05 Thread John Hewson
On 5 Jul 2014, at 13:47, Tilman Hausherr wrote: > Am 05.07.2014 22:12, schrieb John Hewson: > Copyrights is a problem: I'm testing mostly with JIRA attachments that > I've downloaded over the years. While uploading such files to JIRA might > count as fair use, I doubt that this wou

Re: Regression Testing

2014-07-05 Thread Tilman Hausherr
Am 05.07.2014 22:12, schrieb John Hewson: Copyrights is a problem: I'm testing mostly with JIRA attachments that I've downloaded over the years. While uploading such files to JIRA might count as fair use, I doubt that this would still be true if they are included in a distribution. Instead, the

Re: Regression Testing

2014-07-05 Thread John Hewson
>>> Copyrights is a problem: I'm testing mostly with JIRA attachments that I've >>> downloaded over the years. While uploading such files to JIRA might count >>> as fair use, I doubt that this would still be true if they are included in >>> a distribution. Instead, they should be stored somewhe

Re: Regression Testing

2014-07-05 Thread Tilman Hausherr
Am 04.07.2014 19:39, schrieb John Hewson: Hi Tilman Thanks for your thoughts, I think that your concerns are already covered by my original proposal, I’ll try to explain why and how: Of course I agree with the need for regression tests, however it isn't easy: besides the problems of the diff

Re: Regression Testing

2014-07-05 Thread Maruan Sahyoun
> Hi Tilman > > Thanks for your thoughts, I think that your concerns are already covered by > my original proposal, I’ll try to explain why and how: > >> Of course I agree with the need for regression tests, however it isn't easy: >> besides the problems of the different JDKs (I use JDK7 Windo

Re: Regression Testing

2014-07-04 Thread John Hewson
Hi Maruan Thanks for your thoughts... > # Tests # > In addition to rendering we shall be covering metadata and text extraction as > well as PDF/A validation. Yes, we could add extracted text and validation results to the “regression” SVN repo also. > # Testfiles # > Recently there were a nu

Re: Regression Testing

2014-07-04 Thread John Hewson
Hi Tilman Thanks for your thoughts, I think that your concerns are already covered by my original proposal, I’ll try to explain why and how: > Of course I agree with the need for regression tests, however it isn't easy: > besides the problems of the different JDKs (I use JDK7 Windows 64 bit), t

Re: Regression Testing

2014-07-04 Thread Tilman Hausherr
Of course I agree with the need for regression tests, however it isn't easy: besides the problems of the different JDKs (I use JDK7 Windows 64 bit), there is the problem that some enhancements create slight changes in rendering that are not errors, i.e. both the "before" and the "after" files l

Re: Regression Testing

2014-07-03 Thread Maruan Sahyoun
Hi John, thanks for binging this up. This is a very important topic which was also discussed at the PDFDays in Germany. # Tests # In addition to rendering we shall be covering metadata and text extraction as well as PDF/A validation. # Testfiles # Recently there were a number of test sets m