Re: [sc-dev] Please add CSV-export to Export-Dialog

2008-10-30 Thread Niklas Nebel

On 10/30/08 00:51, Leonard Mada wrote:

Please add the CSV-format to the Export-Dialog as suggested in issue 32684.
http://www.openoffice.org/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=32684


See issue 11393. That would be a change in framework, not in Calc. 
Currently, Export shows those formats that only have export, not 
import, filters.


Niklas

-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]



[sc-dev] Please add CSV-export to Export-Dialog

2008-10-29 Thread Leonard Mada

Dear developers,

Please add the CSV-format to the Export-Dialog as suggested in issue 32684.
http://www.openoffice.org/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=32684

After a long absence from the statistical horizon (I basically did not 
have any scheduled work with advanced statistics over the last 2 years), 
I began over the past 2-3 weeks to dwell again in statistics. There are 
obvious reasons why I do all my work in R, so I need to export a lot of 
csv-files.


Unfortunately, there is NO such option in Calc. You can only 'SAVE' as 
csv, which is nonsense. As the csv is really an intermediary transport 
file used to transfer *one sheet* of data from the spreadsheet to 
another program, I strongly support adding the CSV-format to the 
EXPORT-possibilities.


The csv can't support formatting nor formulas, BUT most importantly, 
only the *active sheet* is exported, so it is really ONLY an export, NOT 
a SAVE  AS-functionality.


I therefore strongly suggest to add this option to the EXPORT-dialog.

This has some practical consequences, because it is impossible to 
perform any sound statistics in Calc. At the same time, the ODF-format 
has become too complex to implement accurate file-readers (that mimic 
all its bugs and limitations) in professional statistic packages. It is 
therefore imperative to use a simple format for data-transfer, and csv 
is simply the best suited one (tab-delimited data is another one).


I therefore strongly hope that this enhancement gets implemented in Calc.

Basically, the export-dialog should have both PDF and CSV as options. 
Selecting CSV should export the active sheet, using the sheet-name as 
default name. The status of the ods-file should not change (i.e. do not 
set changed status). That's it.


Sincerely,

Leonard


-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]