Re: [DISCUSS] Sentry roadmap after 2.0

2018-02-02 Thread Stephen Moist
role is not included when sending delta >>>>>> update from Sentry to NN. *Need to add AddUsers and DropUsers >>>>>> in TRoleChanges*. >>>>>> - Sentry only create ACL for group with ACL type >>>>>> as AclEntryType.GROUP. *Need

Re: [DISCUSS] Sentry roadmap after 2.0

2018-01-25 Thread Alexander Kolbasov
o add AddUsers and DropUsers > >>>>> in TRoleChanges*. > >>>>> - Sentry only create ACL for group with ACL type > >>>>> as AclEntryType.GROUP. *Need to add code to create ACL with type > >>>>> as *AclEntryTyp

Re: [DISCUSS] Sentry roadmap after 2.0

2018-01-25 Thread Stephen Moist
type >>>>> as *AclEntryType.USER >>>>> - SentryINodeAttributesProvider.checkPermission >>>>> -> FSPermissionChecker.checkPermission -> >>>>> SentryINodeAttributesProvider.getAclFeature >>>>>

Re: [DISCUSS] Sentry roadmap after 2.0

2018-01-25 Thread Na Li
t; - SentryINodeAttributesProvider.checkPermission > >> > -> FSPermissionChecker.checkPermission -> > >> > SentryINodeAttributesProvider.getAclFeature > >> > -> SentryAuthorizationInfo.getAclEntries -> > SentryP

Re: [DISCUSS] Sentry roadmap after 2.0

2018-01-25 Thread Alexander Kolbasov
AclFeature >> > -> SentryAuthorizationInfo.getAclEntries -> SentryPermissions. >> > constructAclEntry >> > - SentryStore.grantOptionCheck() has to be changed to find user >> >level privilege. >> > >> > Thanks, >

Re: [DISCUSS] Sentry roadmap after 2.0

2018-01-25 Thread Sergio Pena
would it make sense to create one? > > - Alex > > On Thu, Jan 25, 2018 at 11:13 AM, Sergio Pena > wrote: > > > There is a section on the Wiki about roadmap ideas and JIRAs already > > created: > > https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/SENTRY/ > &g

Re: [DISCUSS] Sentry roadmap after 2.0

2018-01-25 Thread Alexander Kolbasov
> SentryPermissions. > > constructAclEntry > > - SentryStore.grantOptionCheck() has to be changed to find user > >level privilege. > > > > Thanks, > > > > Lina > > > > On Thu, Jan 25, 2018 at 1:13 PM, Sergio Pena > >

Re: [DISCUSS] Sentry roadmap after 2.0

2018-01-25 Thread Alexander Kolbasov
el >privilege. > > Thanks, > > Lina > > On Thu, Jan 25, 2018 at 1:13 PM, Sergio Pena > wrote: > > > There is a section on the Wiki about roadmap ideas and JIRAs already > > created: > > https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/SENTRY/ > > Se

Re: [DISCUSS] Sentry roadmap after 2.0

2018-01-25 Thread Na Li
rantOptionCheck() has to be changed to find user >level privilege. > > Thanks, > > Lina > > On Thu, Jan 25, 2018 at 1:13 PM, Sergio Pena > wrote: > >> There is a section on the Wiki about roadmap ideas and JIRAs already >> created: >> https://cwiki

Re: [DISCUSS] Sentry roadmap after 2.0

2018-01-25 Thread Na Li
2018 at 1:13 PM, Sergio Pena wrote: > There is a section on the Wiki about roadmap ideas and JIRAs already > created: > https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/SENTRY/ > Sentry+Roadmap+and+ideas > > I'm interested in having user-level privileges and special user privile

Re: [DISCUSS] Sentry roadmap after 2.0

2018-01-25 Thread Alexander Kolbasov
neral? If not, would it make sense to create one? - Alex On Thu, Jan 25, 2018 at 11:13 AM, Sergio Pena wrote: > There is a section on the Wiki about roadmap ideas and JIRAs already > created: > https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/SENTRY/ > Sentry+Roadmap+and+ideas > > I

Re: [DISCUSS] Sentry roadmap after 2.0

2018-01-25 Thread Sergio Pena
There is a section on the Wiki about roadmap ideas and JIRAs already created: https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/SENTRY/Sentry+Roadmap+and+ideas I'm interested in having user-level privileges and special user privileges for objects owners. I got this from the linked above: SENTRY

Re: [DISCUSS] Sentry roadmap after 2.0

2018-01-25 Thread Kalyan Kumar Kalvagadda
I would like to add something here. 1. Current support for user-based-privileges allows admin to grant a role to user. Ideally, user-based-privileges feature should be allowing administrator to grant privileges to individual users directly. - I'm working on this to come up with a

Re: [DISCUSS] Sentry roadmap after 2.0

2018-01-25 Thread Alexander Kolbasov
Good point. There is some support for user-level privileges in 2.0 already - do you think that it is not sufficient and is missing some parts? Is there anyone reading this who participated in the user-level privileges in Sentry work done earlier? Is there any design doc for this? - Alex On Thu,

Re: [DISCUSS] Sentry roadmap after 2.0

2018-01-25 Thread Na Li
Sasha, It would be nice to have more features for sentry. For example, make user-based privileges working. So user can assign user directly to a role instead of through group. Lina On Thu, Jan 25, 2018 at 11:58 AM, Alexander Kolbasov wrote: > Now that we have Sentry 2.0 release, I think it is

[DISCUSS] Sentry roadmap after 2.0

2018-01-25 Thread Alexander Kolbasov
Now that we have Sentry 2.0 release, I think it is a good time to step back from fixing bugs and immediate problems and start discussions on roadmap for Sentry going forward. Do we want to just keep it as is and improve things here and there or we want to add new features? What do people think? -

Re: Sentry roadmap

2017-02-06 Thread Alexander Kolbasov
> On Feb 5, 2017, at 4:24 AM, Bruno Quinart wrote: > > Hi dev Hi Bruno, > > Is there a roadmap to a new version of Sentry available? Sentry HA is a major new feature, but there is no particular reason preventing a new release of Sentry cut before that if there is a critical mass of features.

Sentry roadmap

2017-02-05 Thread Bruno Quinart
Hi dev Is there a roadmap to a new version of Sentry available? It seems there is a lot of work going on (for example related to HA). However, just based on the wiki and the mailing list, it's hard to understand what is done or how much further work is needed. I am personally interested in SEN