Re: Future of the cross-dc work

It has integration tests, Kafka has an embedded version for tests, just no CI setup currently. If it comes into Solr, it will just pick up Solr’s CI. The design can work with any queuing system, but due to the various intricacies involved in the different queue implementations, adding support is b

Re: Future of the cross-dc work

Hi Anshum, I mostly agree with you. My point is that we shouldn't *release* it until broader community has had a chance to weigh in, both development and testing. Towards that, I like Jan's idea of using PRs etc for more code reviews, before merging it to some official branch. I'm not comfortable

Re: Future of the cross-dc work

Hi, There has for sure been interest since CDCR disappeared. Given the close integration with Solr and its small footprint, I’m supportive of this becoming a Solr module with URP and a standalone app in the main repo. So the code can be cleaned up, documented and migrated over in a few PRs as a

Re: Future of the cross-dc work

I wouldn't term people who work at a particular company as committers. I'm reasonably sure when folks contribute to the project they wear their ASF hat. If they don't, they should. Like most other features, this one also is a result of the need by users of the project. I completely agree it's bee

Re: Discuss SIP-14 Embedded Zookeeper

+1 fully support this, also support the move for us to get rid of the standalone Solr mode. On Sat, 9 Sept, 2023, 5:12 pm Eric Pugh, wrote: > The baby step that Jan is proposing for a ‘zookeeper’ node-role makes > sense to me, for those who are only deploying a very small Solr setup. > > What wo

Re: Discuss SIP-14 Embedded Zookeeper

The baby step that Jan is proposing for a ‘zookeeper’ node-role makes sense to me, for those who are only deploying a very small Solr setup. What would that look like?Would you start your solr like this?I looked a bit at the Ref Guide page for Nodes, and I’m gathering it might look li

SIP-15 Node Roles

Is SIP-15 actually complete? It says “Discussion”, but I noticed a Ref Guide etc…. https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/SOLR/SIP-15+Node+roles ___ Eric Pugh | Founder & CEO | OpenSource Connections, LLC | 434.466.1467 | http://www.opensourceconnections.com

Re: Future of the cross-dc work

So far, this project has been an experimental project, mainly something that's being used and developed by Apple committers. I would be hesitant to support an official Apache release for the same without testing or interest by the broader community. Towards that, can we invite community members to