Re: SolrJ collection creation API, replica type specificity

2024-05-08 Thread David Smiley
For handlers on a core or collection, defaults are easy to specify in a in solrconfig.xml. It'd be cool if we could have a solr.xml that specifies handlers, and with deeper specificity to the operations. Kind of a shame to have these dispatching handlers; if it were at the admin operation level

Re: SolrJ collection creation API, replica type specificity

2024-05-03 Thread David Smiley
I totally understand that the client should be empowered to be specific, and it is right now. But I also think we should support the client being unspecific, and instead allow Solr service owners via Solr-side configuration to choose what makes sense. Where I work, there are different teams

Re: SolrJ collection creation API, replica type specificity

2024-05-03 Thread Jason Gerlowski
You didn't mention it by name, but it sounds like you're talking about the v1 API's "replicationFactor" parameter (which has defaulted to creating NRT replicas for awhile now)? Personally, I'd rather see that parameter (and corresponding SolrJ code) go away altogether. Some things (e.g. the