Re: updateLog tlog directory config silently ignored (SOLR-16962)

2024-01-08 Thread Michael Gibney
Any further thoughts on this? I'd like to proceed with the PR for SOLR-16962 [1], which I've updated with a fix to address now-once-again-relevant SOLR-6537 [2] (at whatever point SOLR-16962 made it impossible to configure an external tlog, SOLR-6537 (cleanup/deletion of external tlog) became

Re: updateLog tlog directory config silently ignored (SOLR-16962)

2023-09-11 Thread Michael Gibney
> useful to separate the location to use some fast local SSDs vs slower but > larger storage for the main index Exactly. And yes, the duplicity of nomenclature is a large part of what I'm suggesting to deal with here ... it's very confusing. But having recently been pretty deep in this part of

Re: updateLog tlog directory config silently ignored (SOLR-16962)

2023-09-11 Thread David Smiley
FWIW I've never heard of anyone customizing that. I suppose it might be useful to separate the location to use some fast local SSDs vs slower but larger storage for the main index? I've noticed an annoying duplicity in nomenclature here -- is it the Update Log or the Transaction Log? And

Re: updateLog tlog directory config silently ignored (SOLR-16962)

2023-09-11 Thread Michael Gibney
Thanks Ilan, this seems good. In addition to addressing practical concerns, this could also be an opportunity to clarify the semantics around updateLog/tlog configuration: In looking closely at this code, my understanding is that the `${solr.ulog.dir:}` setting in solrconfig.xml currently defines

Re: updateLog tlog directory config silently ignored (SOLR-16962)

2023-09-08 Thread Ilan Ginzburg
Re backcompat issue: might be an option to fix that config but use a different name for it then, so that any currently existing (and ignored) config continues to be ignored. Ilan On Thu, Sep 7, 2023, 6:14 PM Michael Gibney wrote: > I'd like to call some extra attention to SOLR-16962 [1]. I'm

updateLog tlog directory config silently ignored (SOLR-16962)

2023-09-07 Thread Michael Gibney
I'd like to call some extra attention to SOLR-16962 [1]. I'm fairly certain that it's been years since it has actually worked to specify tlog dir in solrconfig.xml `` element. I've opened a PR that fixes this, but it involves making some decisions about edge-case handling, for which I'd appreciate