RE: How to support dependency jars and files on HDFS in standalone cluster mode?
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-8369 Created And I’m working on a PR. Thanks Dong Lei From: Cheng Lian [mailto:lian.cs@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, June 12, 2015 7:03 PM To: Dong Lei Cc: Dianfei (Keith) Han; dev@spark.apache.org Subject: Re: How to support dependency jars and files on HDFS in standalone cluster mode? Would you mind to file a JIRA for this? Thanks! Cheng On 6/11/15 2:40 PM, Dong Lei wrote: I think in standalone cluster mode, spark is supposed to do: 1. Download jars, files to driver 2. Set the driver’s class path 3. Driver setup a http file server to distribute these files 4. Worker download from driver and setup classpath Right? But somehow, the first step fails. Even if I can make the first step works(use option1), it seems that the classpath in driver is not correctly set. Thanks Dong Lei From: Cheng Lian [mailto:lian.cs@gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, June 11, 2015 2:32 PM To: Dong Lei Cc: Dianfei (Keith) Han; dev@spark.apache.orgmailto:dev@spark.apache.org Subject: Re: How to support dependency jars and files on HDFS in standalone cluster mode? Oh sorry, I mistook --jars for --files. Yeah, for jars we need to add them to classpath, which is different from regular files. Cheng On 6/11/15 2:18 PM, Dong Lei wrote: Thanks Cheng, If I do not use --jars how can I tell spark to search the jars(and files) on HDFS? Do you mean the driver will not need to setup a HTTP file server for this scenario and the worker will fetch the jars and files from HDFS? Thanks Dong Lei From: Cheng Lian [mailto:lian.cs@gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, June 11, 2015 12:50 PM To: Dong Lei; dev@spark.apache.orgmailto:dev@spark.apache.org Cc: Dianfei (Keith) Han Subject: Re: How to support dependency jars and files on HDFS in standalone cluster mode? Since the jars are already on HDFS, you can access them directly in your Spark application without using --jars Cheng On 6/11/15 11:04 AM, Dong Lei wrote: Hi spark-dev: I can not use a hdfs location for the “--jars” or “--files” option when doing a spark-submit in a standalone cluster mode. For example: Spark-submit … --jars hdfs://ip/1.jar …. hdfs://ip/app.jar (standalone cluster mode) will not download 1.jar to driver’s http file server(but the app.jar will be downloaded to the driver’s dir). I figure out the reason spark not downloading the jars is that when doing sc.addJar to http file server, the function called is Files.copy which does not support a remote location. And I think if spark can download the jars and add them to http file server, the classpath is not correctly set, because the classpath contains remote location. So I’m trying to make it work and come up with two options, but neither of them seem to be elegant, and I want to hear your advices: Option 1: Modify HTTPFileServer.addFileToDir, let it recognize a “hdfs” prefix. This is not good because I think it breaks the scope of http file server. Option 2: Modify DriverRunner.downloadUserJar, let it download all the “--jars” and “--files” with the application jar. This sounds more reasonable that option 1 for downloading files. But this way I need to read the “spark.jars” and “spark.files” on downloadUserJar or DriverRunnder.start and replace it with a local path. How can I do that? Do you have a more elegant solution, or do we have a plan to support it in the furture? Thanks Dong Lei
Re: How to support dependency jars and files on HDFS in standalone cluster mode?
Would you mind to file a JIRA for this? Thanks! Cheng On 6/11/15 2:40 PM, Dong Lei wrote: I think in standalone cluster mode, spark is supposed to do: 1.Download jars, files to driver 2.Set the driver’s class path 3.Driver setup a http file server to distribute these files 4.Worker download from driver and setup classpath Right? But somehow, the first step fails. Even if I can make the first step works(use option1), it seems that the classpath in driver is not correctly set. Thanks Dong Lei *From:*Cheng Lian [mailto:lian.cs@gmail.com] *Sent:* Thursday, June 11, 2015 2:32 PM *To:* Dong Lei *Cc:* Dianfei (Keith) Han; dev@spark.apache.org *Subject:* Re: How to support dependency jars and files on HDFS in standalone cluster mode? Oh sorry, I mistook --jars for --files. Yeah, for jars we need to add them to classpath, which is different from regular files. Cheng On 6/11/15 2:18 PM, Dong Lei wrote: Thanks Cheng, If I do not use --jars how can I tell spark to search the jars(and files) on HDFS? Do you mean the driver will not need to setup a HTTP file server for this scenario and the worker will fetch the jars and files from HDFS? Thanks Dong Lei *From:*Cheng Lian [mailto:lian.cs@gmail.com] *Sent:* Thursday, June 11, 2015 12:50 PM *To:* Dong Lei; dev@spark.apache.org mailto:dev@spark.apache.org *Cc:* Dianfei (Keith) Han *Subject:* Re: How to support dependency jars and files on HDFS in standalone cluster mode? Since the jars are already on HDFS, you can access them directly in your Spark application without using --jars Cheng On 6/11/15 11:04 AM, Dong Lei wrote: Hi spark-dev: I can not use a hdfs location for the “--jars” or “--files” option when doing a spark-submit in a standalone cluster mode. For example: Spark-submit … --jars hdfs://ip/1.jar …. hdfs://ip/app.jar (standalone cluster mode) will not download 1.jar to driver’s http file server(but the app.jar will be downloaded to the driver’s dir). I figure out the reason spark not downloading the jars is that when doing sc.addJar to http file server, the function called is Files.copy which does not support a remote location. And I think if spark can download the jars and add them to http file server, the classpath is not correctly set, because the classpath contains remote location. So I’m trying to make it work and come up with two options, but neither of them seem to be elegant, and I want to hear your advices: Option 1: Modify HTTPFileServer.addFileToDir, let it recognize a “hdfs” prefix. This is not good because I think it breaks the scope of http file server. Option 2: Modify DriverRunner.downloadUserJar, let it download all the “--jars” and “--files” with the application jar. This sounds more reasonable that option 1 for downloading files. But this way I need to read the “spark.jars” and “spark.files” on downloadUserJar or DriverRunnder.start and replace it with a local path. How can I do that? Do you have a more elegant solution, or do we have a plan to support it in the furture? Thanks Dong Lei
Re: How to support dependency jars and files on HDFS in standalone cluster mode?
Oh sorry, I mistook --jars for --files. Yeah, for jars we need to add them to classpath, which is different from regular files. Cheng On 6/11/15 2:18 PM, Dong Lei wrote: Thanks Cheng, If I do not use --jars how can I tell spark to search the jars(and files) on HDFS? Do you mean the driver will not need to setup a HTTP file server for this scenario and the worker will fetch the jars and files from HDFS? Thanks Dong Lei *From:*Cheng Lian [mailto:lian.cs@gmail.com] *Sent:* Thursday, June 11, 2015 12:50 PM *To:* Dong Lei; dev@spark.apache.org *Cc:* Dianfei (Keith) Han *Subject:* Re: How to support dependency jars and files on HDFS in standalone cluster mode? Since the jars are already on HDFS, you can access them directly in your Spark application without using --jars Cheng On 6/11/15 11:04 AM, Dong Lei wrote: Hi spark-dev: I can not use a hdfs location for the “--jars” or “--files” option when doing a spark-submit in a standalone cluster mode. For example: Spark-submit … --jars hdfs://ip/1.jar …. hdfs://ip/app.jar (standalone cluster mode) will not download 1.jar to driver’s http file server(but the app.jar will be downloaded to the driver’s dir). I figure out the reason spark not downloading the jars is that when doing sc.addJar to http file server, the function called is Files.copy which does not support a remote location. And I think if spark can download the jars and add them to http file server, the classpath is not correctly set, because the classpath contains remote location. So I’m trying to make it work and come up with two options, but neither of them seem to be elegant, and I want to hear your advices: Option 1: Modify HTTPFileServer.addFileToDir, let it recognize a “hdfs” prefix. This is not good because I think it breaks the scope of http file server. Option 2: Modify DriverRunner.downloadUserJar, let it download all the “--jars” and “--files” with the application jar. This sounds more reasonable that option 1 for downloading files. But this way I need to read the “spark.jars” and “spark.files” on downloadUserJar or DriverRunnder.start and replace it with a local path. How can I do that? Do you have a more elegant solution, or do we have a plan to support it in the furture? Thanks Dong Lei
RE: How to support dependency jars and files on HDFS in standalone cluster mode?
I think in standalone cluster mode, spark is supposed to do: 1. Download jars, files to driver 2. Set the driver’s class path 3. Driver setup a http file server to distribute these files 4. Worker download from driver and setup classpath Right? But somehow, the first step fails. Even if I can make the first step works(use option1), it seems that the classpath in driver is not correctly set. Thanks Dong Lei From: Cheng Lian [mailto:lian.cs@gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, June 11, 2015 2:32 PM To: Dong Lei Cc: Dianfei (Keith) Han; dev@spark.apache.org Subject: Re: How to support dependency jars and files on HDFS in standalone cluster mode? Oh sorry, I mistook --jars for --files. Yeah, for jars we need to add them to classpath, which is different from regular files. Cheng On 6/11/15 2:18 PM, Dong Lei wrote: Thanks Cheng, If I do not use --jars how can I tell spark to search the jars(and files) on HDFS? Do you mean the driver will not need to setup a HTTP file server for this scenario and the worker will fetch the jars and files from HDFS? Thanks Dong Lei From: Cheng Lian [mailto:lian.cs@gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, June 11, 2015 12:50 PM To: Dong Lei; dev@spark.apache.orgmailto:dev@spark.apache.org Cc: Dianfei (Keith) Han Subject: Re: How to support dependency jars and files on HDFS in standalone cluster mode? Since the jars are already on HDFS, you can access them directly in your Spark application without using --jars Cheng On 6/11/15 11:04 AM, Dong Lei wrote: Hi spark-dev: I can not use a hdfs location for the “--jars” or “--files” option when doing a spark-submit in a standalone cluster mode. For example: Spark-submit … --jars hdfs://ip/1.jar …. hdfs://ip/app.jar (standalone cluster mode) will not download 1.jar to driver’s http file server(but the app.jar will be downloaded to the driver’s dir). I figure out the reason spark not downloading the jars is that when doing sc.addJar to http file server, the function called is Files.copy which does not support a remote location. And I think if spark can download the jars and add them to http file server, the classpath is not correctly set, because the classpath contains remote location. So I’m trying to make it work and come up with two options, but neither of them seem to be elegant, and I want to hear your advices: Option 1: Modify HTTPFileServer.addFileToDir, let it recognize a “hdfs” prefix. This is not good because I think it breaks the scope of http file server. Option 2: Modify DriverRunner.downloadUserJar, let it download all the “--jars” and “--files” with the application jar. This sounds more reasonable that option 1 for downloading files. But this way I need to read the “spark.jars” and “spark.files” on downloadUserJar or DriverRunnder.start and replace it with a local path. How can I do that? Do you have a more elegant solution, or do we have a plan to support it in the furture? Thanks Dong Lei
RE: How to support dependency jars and files on HDFS in standalone cluster mode?
Thanks Cheng, If I do not use --jars how can I tell spark to search the jars(and files) on HDFS? Do you mean the driver will not need to setup a HTTP file server for this scenario and the worker will fetch the jars and files from HDFS? Thanks Dong Lei From: Cheng Lian [mailto:lian.cs@gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, June 11, 2015 12:50 PM To: Dong Lei; dev@spark.apache.org Cc: Dianfei (Keith) Han Subject: Re: How to support dependency jars and files on HDFS in standalone cluster mode? Since the jars are already on HDFS, you can access them directly in your Spark application without using --jars Cheng On 6/11/15 11:04 AM, Dong Lei wrote: Hi spark-dev: I can not use a hdfs location for the --jars or --files option when doing a spark-submit in a standalone cluster mode. For example: Spark-submit ... --jars hdfs://ip/1.jar hdfs://ip/app.jar (standalone cluster mode) will not download 1.jar to driver's http file server(but the app.jar will be downloaded to the driver's dir). I figure out the reason spark not downloading the jars is that when doing sc.addJar to http file server, the function called is Files.copy which does not support a remote location. And I think if spark can download the jars and add them to http file server, the classpath is not correctly set, because the classpath contains remote location. So I'm trying to make it work and come up with two options, but neither of them seem to be elegant, and I want to hear your advices: Option 1: Modify HTTPFileServer.addFileToDir, let it recognize a hdfs prefix. This is not good because I think it breaks the scope of http file server. Option 2: Modify DriverRunner.downloadUserJar, let it download all the --jars and --files with the application jar. This sounds more reasonable that option 1 for downloading files. But this way I need to read the spark.jars and spark.files on downloadUserJar or DriverRunnder.start and replace it with a local path. How can I do that? Do you have a more elegant solution, or do we have a plan to support it in the furture? Thanks Dong Lei
Re: How to support dependency jars and files on HDFS in standalone cluster mode?
Since the jars are already on HDFS, you can access them directly in your Spark application without using --jars Cheng On 6/11/15 11:04 AM, Dong Lei wrote: Hi spark-dev: I can not use a hdfs location for the “--jars” or “--files” option when doing a spark-submit in a standalone cluster mode. For example: Spark-submit … --jars hdfs://ip/1.jar …. hdfs://ip/app.jar (standalone cluster mode) will not download 1.jar to driver’s http file server(but the app.jar will be downloaded to the driver’s dir). I figure out the reason spark not downloading the jars is that when doing sc.addJar to http file server, the function called is Files.copy which does not support a remote location. And I think if spark can download the jars and add them to http file server, the classpath is not correctly set, because the classpath contains remote location. So I’m trying to make it work and come up with two options, but neither of them seem to be elegant, and I want to hear your advices: Option 1: Modify HTTPFileServer.addFileToDir, let it recognize a “hdfs” prefix. This is not good because I think it breaks the scope of http file server. Option 2: Modify DriverRunner.downloadUserJar, let it download all the “--jars” and “--files” with the application jar. This sounds more reasonable that option 1 for downloading files. But this way I need to read the “spark.jars” and “spark.files” on downloadUserJar or DriverRunnder.start and replace it with a local path. How can I do that? Do you have a more elegant solution, or do we have a plan to support it in the furture? Thanks Dong Lei
How to support dependency jars and files on HDFS in standalone cluster mode?
Hi spark-dev: I can not use a hdfs location for the --jars or --files option when doing a spark-submit in a standalone cluster mode. For example: Spark-submit ... --jars hdfs://ip/1.jar hdfs://ip/app.jar (standalone cluster mode) will not download 1.jar to driver's http file server(but the app.jar will be downloaded to the driver's dir). I figure out the reason spark not downloading the jars is that when doing sc.addJar to http file server, the function called is Files.copy which does not support a remote location. And I think if spark can download the jars and add them to http file server, the classpath is not correctly set, because the classpath contains remote location. So I'm trying to make it work and come up with two options, but neither of them seem to be elegant, and I want to hear your advices: Option 1: Modify HTTPFileServer.addFileToDir, let it recognize a hdfs prefix. This is not good because I think it breaks the scope of http file server. Option 2: Modify DriverRunner.downloadUserJar, let it download all the --jars and --files with the application jar. This sounds more reasonable that option 1 for downloading files. But this way I need to read the spark.jars and spark.files on downloadUserJar or DriverRunnder.start and replace it with a local path. How can I do that? Do you have a more elegant solution, or do we have a plan to support it in the furture? Thanks Dong Lei
