Intent to unship SVGZoomAndPan interface

2019-09-28 Thread longsonr
Hi, In [1] I intend to unship the SVGZoomAndPan interface. The SVG WG decided to remove this interface in [2] as it's either not implemented at all or does nothing in current implementations. Our implementation is currently the "does nothing" kind i.e. you can get and set the property but it

Re: What to do about scroll anchoring?

2019-09-28 Thread Jonathan Kew
On 27/09/2019 23:19, Botond Ballo wrote: Emilio, thanks for all your work on this! On Fri, Sep 27, 2019 at 8:23 AM Emilio Cobos Álvarez wrote: Does anyone have strong opinions against removing scroll anchoring from Gecko, based on the above? My 2c: it would be unfortunate to give up on

Re: What to do about scroll anchoring?

2019-09-28 Thread Cameron McCormack
How useful is scroll anchoring outside of the two cases mentioned in https://drafts.csswg.org/css-scroll-anchoring/#intro i.e. images loading and ad iframes being inserted? Would it be feasible to make scroll anchoring a much less general mechanism, and to scope it down to handling these

Re: Intent to unship SVGZoomAndPan interface

2019-09-28 Thread Cameron McCormack
On Sun, Sep 29, 2019, at 1:22 PM, Boris Zbarsky wrote: > Sure, we could pass that by making it a mixin, not an interface, but > that says nothing about the `zoomAndPan` attribute on SVGSVGElement and > SVGViewElement. What does the compat situation look like for those? Both Chrome and Safari

Re: Intent to unship SVGZoomAndPan interface

2019-09-28 Thread Cameron McCormack
On Sat, Sep 28, 2019, at 11:41 PM, longs...@gmail.com wrote: > In [1] I intend to unship the SVGZoomAndPan interface. The SVG WG > decided to remove this interface in [2] as it's either not implemented > at all or does nothing in current implementations. Our implementation > is currently the

Re: What to do about scroll anchoring?

2019-09-28 Thread L. David Baron
On Sunday 2019-09-29 10:54 +1000, Cameron McCormack wrote: > How useful is scroll anchoring outside of the two cases mentioned in > https://drafts.csswg.org/css-scroll-anchoring/#intro i.e. images loading and > ad iframes being inserted? Would it be feasible to make scroll anchoring a > much

Re: Intent to unship SVGZoomAndPan interface

2019-09-28 Thread Boris Zbarsky
On 9/28/19 9:41 AM, longs...@gmail.com wrote: In [1] I intend to unship the SVGZoomAndPan interface. To be clear, this is unshipping that interface _and_ the mixin onto elements that adds a `zoomAndPan` attribute on them, right? The SVG WG decided to remove this interface in [2] as it's