Re: RTC voting and in particular pluggable jacc issue
Yes...+1I have changed my practice and place a comment in the JIRA. I think I voted before changing my practice ;-) David Jencks wrote: > AFAICT it's not possible to find out from jira when votes on issues were > done, nor do they get comments. Therefore I think we need to ask PMC > members voting on RTC issues to both vote and include a comment > explicitly indicating that they are voting +1 as an official RTC vote. > > In particular GERONIMO-1563 pluggable jacc has 3 pmc votes but only 2 > comments from pmc members specifically indicating a +1 RTC vote. I have > no way to determine if Jeff's vote was before or after he rejoined the > PMC. Jeff, could you clarify? > > thanks > david jencks
Re: RTC voting and in particular pluggable jacc issue
Agreed, the JIRA coting mechanism is auxilary and only to help show in the review reports, but votes need to be make in comments. The JIRA voting mechanism has no history, does not trigger an email and includes no detail, so this must not be used as official votes. --jason On Aug 9, 2006, at 11:21 AM, David Jencks wrote: AFAICT it's not possible to find out from jira when votes on issues were done, nor do they get comments. Therefore I think we need to ask PMC members voting on RTC issues to both vote and include a comment explicitly indicating that they are voting +1 as an official RTC vote. In particular GERONIMO-1563 pluggable jacc has 3 pmc votes but only 2 comments from pmc members specifically indicating a +1 RTC vote. I have no way to determine if Jeff's vote was before or after he rejoined the PMC. Jeff, could you clarify? thanks david jencks
Re: RTC voting and in particular pluggable jacc issue
I generally vote and post a comment. I like the idea David. David Jencks wrote: AFAICT it's not possible to find out from jira when votes on issues were done, nor do they get comments. Therefore I think we need to ask PMC members voting on RTC issues to both vote and include a comment explicitly indicating that they are voting +1 as an official RTC vote. In particular GERONIMO-1563 pluggable jacc has 3 pmc votes but only 2 comments from pmc members specifically indicating a +1 RTC vote. I have no way to determine if Jeff's vote was before or after he rejoined the PMC. Jeff, could you clarify? thanks david jencks
