Re: What's up with JEE6? Are we doing it in 2.2?

2008-09-23 Thread Kevan Miller


On Sep 23, 2008, at 11:50 AM, Tim McConnell wrote:

Hi Ted, yes I have been assuming the same as well. At a minimal I  
would like to volunteer to understand and analyze the implications  
of JEE6 to the GEP


Ted Kirby wrote:

Who's doing what?
I sort of assumed that 2.2 would have JEE 6 in it, but I can't find
any information about it.


No, not in 2.2.

G 2.2 will have Java SE 6 support, but will be Java EE 5 certified. At  
least that's been my assumption (and others, I think). Prolly  
worthwhile updating the 2.2. release roadmap to avoid possible  
confusion... There are some barriers to supporting Java EE 6 -- a Java  
EE 6 Initial Specification hasn't been released yet, let alone a final  
spec or TCK... ;-) Also, many of the technology specs (EJB 3.1,  
Servlet 3.0, JPA 2.0, JSF 2.0) are still being defined -- there are  
some early drafts of some of these specs.


Note that G 2.2 will have some features that are expected to be in EE  
6. With our component-based capabilities, we've had the concept of a  
"Web Profile" since our 1.1.1 release. We have way more capabilities,  
in this regard, then the spec will call for... Plus, we'll have JAX-WS  
2.1/JAX-B 2.1 support. We'll also have JASPI support (w/ Jetty 7 --  
which will also contain Servlet 3.0 features). OpenEJB 3.1 will also  
contain some aspects of the EJB 3.1 spec.  I may be missing others...


IMO, it's too early for an EE 6 "roadmap". However, definitely  
something that's on our horizon...


--kevan



Re: What's up with JEE6? Are we doing it in 2.2?

2008-09-23 Thread David Jencks


On Sep 23, 2008, at 8:50 AM, Tim McConnell wrote:

Hi Ted, yes I have been assuming the same as well. At a minimal I  
would like to volunteer to understand and analyze the implications  
of JEE6 to the GEP


It would be great if someone would investigate and report on what the  
current contents of jee6 are.   IIRC Dave Klavon (?) made some kind of  
roadmap for jee5 which although very coarse grained was somewhat  
helpful.  The stuff I know about targeted for 2.2 are:


jaspi
jacc updates (hopefully)
j2ca updates (maybe)
servlet 3 in jetty 7

ejb 3.1
jaxws 2.1

Having a jee6 section on http://cwiki.apache.org/GMOxPMGT/geronimo-22-release-roadmap.html 
 might be nice.


thanks
david jencks




Ted Kirby wrote:

Who's doing what?
I sort of assumed that 2.2 would have JEE 6 in it, but I can't find
any information about it.
Thanks,
Ted Kirby


--
Thanks,
Tim McConnell




Re: What's up with JEE6? Are we doing it in 2.2?

2008-09-23 Thread Tim McConnell
Hi Ted, yes I have been assuming the same as well. At a minimal I would like to 
volunteer to understand and analyze the implications of JEE6 to the GEP


Ted Kirby wrote:

Who's doing what?

I sort of assumed that 2.2 would have JEE 6 in it, but I can't find
any information about it.

Thanks,
Ted Kirby



--
Thanks,
Tim McConnell