Re: Add pacing feature

2020-04-26 Thread Philippe Mouawad
See the other thread, it does not seem to work On Sunday, April 26, 2020, Vladimir Sitnikov wrote: > >- Step 1 : X req/s > >- Step 2 : Y req/s > >- Step 3 : Y req/s > >I am not sure it is feasible with PTT. > > It should be feasible if a variable is used in PTT throughput. > > Vladimir > --

Re: Add pacing feature

2020-04-26 Thread Vladimir Sitnikov
>- Step 1 : X req/s >- Step 2 : Y req/s >- Step 3 : Y req/s >I am not sure it is feasible with PTT. It should be feasible if a variable is used in PTT throughput. Vladimir

Re: Add pacing feature

2020-04-26 Thread Philippe Mouawad
Hello Vladimir, >From schema that Vincent sent in another thread , I guess what is requested here is ability to do steps: - Step 1 : X req/s - Step 2 : Y req/s - Step 3 : Y req/s I am not sure it is feasible with PTT. Regards On Mon, Apr 20, 2020 at 2:57 PM Vladimir Sitnikov <

Re: Add pacing feature

2020-04-20 Thread Vladimir Sitnikov
>for compute by groovy code the pacing I'm afraid I don't follow you here. Can you please clarify why the current Precise Throughput Timer does not work for your "pacing" scenario? Vladimir

Re: Add pacing feature

2020-04-20 Thread Vincent Daburon
Hi, > *If we had notion of try/finally, it could be doable and solve also other requirements like ensuring a session is disconnected even if error occurs* Yes if we can set a module controler or test frament for the finally is could be a good solution for logout or for compute by groovy code the

Re: Add pacing feature

2020-04-20 Thread Vladimir Sitnikov
Image test : [image: schema_pacing_4_iter_v3.png] Vladimir

Re: Add pacing feature

2020-04-17 Thread Vladimir Sitnikov
Vincent, I'm not sure why do you call it pacing, but what you draw is exactly what JMeter's Precise Throughput Timer is doing. If you place the timer under a "flow control action" which is before sampler1, then the timer would delay the theads that come to early. Have you tried it? Does it work

Re: Add pacing feature

2020-04-17 Thread Vincent Daburon
Hi, I complete pacing schema with 4 iterations : 1st iteration, sum of sampler durations < pacing 2sd iteration, *error *and Thread Group action : " *Start Next Thread Loop*" 3th iteration, sum of sampler durations *>* pacing 4th iteration, sum of sampler durations < pacing

Re: Add pacing feature

2020-04-16 Thread Vincent Daburon
Hi, I put images on this topic https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/ptgram24/f2OVAIWazl8 Regards. Vincent DAB. Le jeu. 16 avr. 2020 à 14:45, Vincent Daburon a écrit : > Hi, > When you make load test with load steps, the pacing is useful. > 1st step 50% of the load > 2sd step 100% of the

Re: Add pacing feature

2020-04-16 Thread Vincent Daburon
Hi, When you make load test with load steps, the pacing is useful. 1st step 50% of the load 2sd step 100% of the load 3thd step 150% of the load [image: Active_Threads_ALL_Over_Time.png] The pacing for an iteration is constant and the number of samplers is proportional to the number of threads

Re: Add pacing feature

2020-04-16 Thread Vladimir Sitnikov
>[image: schema_pacing_v1.png] Unfortunately, the images are not yet enabled in this mailing list. I've filed https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/INFRA-20125 to fix that. Could you please upload the image to gist.github.com or something like that in the mean time? Vladimir

Re: Add pacing feature

2020-04-16 Thread Vincent Daburon
Hi a little schema to explain the pacing for an iteration for 1 thread The waiting time to complete the pacing is a dynamic waiting time. [image: schema_pacing_v1.png] Regards. Vincent DAB. Le jeu. 16 avr. 2020 à 13:32, Vladimir Sitnikov a écrit : > Philippe>- you don’t have a requirement of

Re: Add pacing feature

2020-04-16 Thread Vladimir Sitnikov
Philippe>- you don’t have a requirement of number of execution per minute How do you compute "pacing" then? :) I guess you almost always have something on the number of scenarios per hour :) Philippe>How do you avoid a burst in the first steps (the one before failure) of Philippe>your scenario

Re: Add pacing feature

2020-04-16 Thread Philippe Mouawad
Hello, What about following use case: - You have a number of virtual users running a scenario which is composed of 30 steps related through correlation of ids - You set thread group to Start next thread loop on error - you don’t have a requirement of number of execution per minute How do you

Re: Add pacing feature

2020-04-16 Thread Antonio Gomes Rodrigues
Hi, Pacing is used in Neoload, Loadruner... But I am agree with Vladimir, we can use "Precise Throughput Timer" and "Constant Throughput Timer" Le jeu. 16 avr. 2020 à 12:53, Vladimir Sitnikov a écrit : > Hi, > > >For 3 years I have been using the notion of Pacing an iteration to >

Re: Add pacing feature

2020-04-16 Thread Vladimir Sitnikov
Hi, >For 3 years I have been using the notion of Pacing an iteration to >facilitate the modeling of the load and also because it is very practical >when we are doing loads with load steps Can you please clarify how pacing makes it practical? For instance, I have never faced a case when the