Re: Is there any value to per-Fedora branch ACLs?

2010-12-14 Thread Henrik Nordström
tis 2010-12-07 klockan 10:20 -0800 skrev Jesse Keating: While I'm looking into the git setup and ACLs and all this, I have a question. Is anybody seeing any real value of having different commit ACLs per Fedora branch? I've seen some argument for EPEL vs Fedora, but is there real value in

Re: Is there any value to per-Fedora branch ACLs?

2010-12-10 Thread Kevin Kofler
Jesse Keating wrote: Is anybody seeing any real value of having different commit ACLs per Fedora branch? I've seen some argument for EPEL vs Fedora, but is there real value in ACLs for f13, f14, devel, etc...? No. But the real question is: Is there any value to ACLs at all? Before the big

Re: Is there any value to per-Fedora branch ACLs?

2010-12-08 Thread Michael J Gruber
Toshio Kuratomi venit, vidit, dixit 08.12.2010 01:44: On Tue, Dec 07, 2010 at 10:20:28AM -0800, Jesse Keating wrote: While I'm looking into the git setup and ACLs and all this, I have a question. Is anybody seeing any real value of having different commit ACLs per Fedora branch? I've seen

Is there any value to per-Fedora branch ACLs?

2010-12-07 Thread Jesse Keating
While I'm looking into the git setup and ACLs and all this, I have a question. Is anybody seeing any real value of having different commit ACLs per Fedora branch? I've seen some argument for EPEL vs Fedora, but is there real value in ACLs for f13, f14, devel, etc...? -- Jesse Keating Fedora --

Re: Is there any value to per-Fedora branch ACLs?

2010-12-07 Thread Jeff Spaleta
On Tue, Dec 7, 2010 at 6:20 PM, Jesse Keating jkeat...@redhat.com wrote: While I'm looking into the git setup and ACLs and all this, I have a question. Is anybody seeing any real value of having different commit ACLs per Fedora branch?  I've seen some argument for EPEL vs Fedora, but is there

Re: Is there any value to per-Fedora branch ACLs?

2010-12-07 Thread Roland McGrath
Is anybody seeing any real value of having different commit ACLs per Fedora branch? I've seen some argument for EPEL vs Fedora, but is there real value in ACLs for f13, f14, devel, etc...? The pkgdb interface distinguishes them. Apparently there was some motivation for that in the first

Re: Is there any value to per-Fedora branch ACLs?

2010-12-07 Thread Ian Weller
On Tue, Dec 07, 2010 at 10:20:28AM -0800, Jesse Keating wrote: While I'm looking into the git setup and ACLs and all this, I have a question. Is anybody seeing any real value of having different commit ACLs per Fedora branch? I've seen some argument for EPEL vs Fedora, but is there real

Re: Is there any value to per-Fedora branch ACLs?

2010-12-07 Thread Mamoru Tasaka
Jesse Keating wrote, at 12/08/2010 03:20 AM +9:00: While I'm looking into the git setup and ACLs and all this, I have a question. Is anybody seeing any real value of having different commit ACLs per Fedora branch? I've seen some argument for EPEL vs Fedora, but is there real value in ACLs

Re: Is there any value to per-Fedora branch ACLs?

2010-12-07 Thread Till Maas
On Tue, Dec 07, 2010 at 10:20:28AM -0800, Jesse Keating wrote: While I'm looking into the git setup and ACLs and all this, I have a question. Is anybody seeing any real value of having different commit ACLs per Fedora branch? I've seen some argument for EPEL vs Fedora, but is there real

Re: Is there any value to per-Fedora branch ACLs?

2010-12-07 Thread drago01
On Tue, Dec 7, 2010 at 7:20 PM, Jesse Keating jkeat...@redhat.com wrote: While I'm looking into the git setup and ACLs and all this, I have a question. Is anybody seeing any real value of having different commit ACLs per Fedora branch? No -- devel mailing list devel@lists.fedoraproject.org

Re: Is there any value to per-Fedora branch ACLs?

2010-12-07 Thread Jesse Keating
On 12/07/2010 10:25 AM, Jeff Spaleta wrote: On Tue, Dec 7, 2010 at 6:20 PM, Jesse Keating jkeat...@redhat.com wrote: While I'm looking into the git setup and ACLs and all this, I have a question. Is anybody seeing any real value of having different commit ACLs per Fedora branch? I've seen

Re: Is there any value to per-Fedora branch ACLs?

2010-12-07 Thread Jesse Keating
On 12/07/2010 10:27 AM, Roland McGrath wrote: The pkgdb interface distinguishes them. Apparently there was some motivation for that in the first place. If the git hooks are not going to distinguish them, then pkgdb should change not to either. Currently the git ACLs do enforce per-branch

Re: Is there any value to per-Fedora branch ACLs?

2010-12-07 Thread Jesse Keating
On 12/07/2010 11:22 AM, Mamoru Tasaka wrote: There can be a case that F-13 package and F-14 package are completely different, even if the packages have the same name. For example there may be a case that a package of older version shipped in F-13 is written in perl, and new version shipped

Re: Is there any value to per-Fedora branch ACLs?

2010-12-07 Thread Jesse Keating
On 12/07/2010 11:52 AM, Till Maas wrote: On Tue, Dec 07, 2010 at 10:20:28AM -0800, Jesse Keating wrote: While I'm looking into the git setup and ACLs and all this, I have a question. Is anybody seeing any real value of having different commit ACLs per Fedora branch? I've seen some argument

Re: Is there any value to per-Fedora branch ACLs?

2010-12-07 Thread Till Maas
On Tue, Dec 07, 2010 at 01:55:26PM -0800, Jesse Keating wrote: On 12/07/2010 11:52 AM, Till Maas wrote: On Tue, Dec 07, 2010 at 10:20:28AM -0800, Jesse Keating wrote: While I'm looking into the git setup and ACLs and all this, I have a question. Is anybody seeing any real value of

Re: Is there any value to per-Fedora branch ACLs?

2010-12-07 Thread Jesse Keating
On 12/07/2010 02:25 PM, Till Maas wrote: To properly display the state of the package in PackageDB. E.g. if a package has different owners in different releases, it is more clear who is responsible. E.g. sometimes packages are faded out from Fedora and therefore orphaned in devel, but not in

Re: Is there any value to per-Fedora branch ACLs?

2010-12-07 Thread Toshio Kuratomi
On Tue, Dec 07, 2010 at 10:20:28AM -0800, Jesse Keating wrote: While I'm looking into the git setup and ACLs and all this, I have a question. Is anybody seeing any real value of having different commit ACLs per Fedora branch? I've seen some argument for EPEL vs Fedora, but is there real