Re: tap-to-click feedback

2010-04-15 Thread Sebastian Silva
We saw this issue in our work with the Cantagallo comunity school here in Lima. Tuukka and Kaisa saw it in the teacher training they attended, it seems to be very confusing for new users, who have never used a touchpad before (they tend to touch the pad gently and briefly, obtaining a click

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2010-04-15 Thread Sebastian Silva
BTW how do you disable it? There is a thread about the subject currently on OLPC-Uruguay. http://lists.laptop.org/pipermail/olpc-uruguay/2010-April/002075.html Sebastian 2010/4/15 Sebastian Silva sebast...@fuentelibre.org We saw this issue in our work with the Cantagallo comunity school here

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2010-04-15 Thread Martin Langhoff
On Thu, Apr 15, 2010 at 11:34 AM, Sebastian Silva sebast...@fuentelibre.org wrote: BTW how do you disable it? Yeah -- can we disable it easily on F11 builds? m -- martin.langh...@gmail.com mar...@laptop.org -- School Server Architect - ask interesting questions - don't get distracted

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2010-04-15 Thread Daniel Drake
On 15 April 2010 11:40, Martin Langhoff martin.langh...@gmail.com wrote: On Thu, Apr 15, 2010 at 11:34 AM, Sebastian Silva sebast...@fuentelibre.org wrote: BTW how do you disable it? Yeah -- can we disable it easily on F11 builds? (speaking only for XO) No. We would have to change mouse

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2010-04-15 Thread Stanley Sokolow
I have an old HP laptop with tap-to-click turned on by default when there's no external mouse. It is annoying to be typing text and have your thumb accidentally brush the touchpad and suddenly you're typing in a totally different location in the text, wherever the mouse pointer happened to be

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2010-04-15 Thread Paul Fox
daniel wrote: On 15 April 2010 11:40, Martin Langhoff martin.langh...@gmail.com wrote: On Thu, Apr 15, 2010 at 11:34 AM, Sebastian Silva sebast...@fuentelibre.org wrote: BTW how do you disable it? Yeah -- can we disable it easily on F11 builds? (speaking only for XO) No. We

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2010-04-15 Thread Ed McNierney
Paul - This issue has bubbled up from time to time over the last 18 months or so (judging from my email archives). It is not at all clear to me that there is indeed a consensus from deployments; some like it, some don't. We tend to (unsurprisingly) hear little or nothing from the people who

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2010-04-15 Thread Richard Smith
On Thu, Apr 15, 2010 at 11:24 AM, Ed McNierney e...@laptop.org wrote: Paul - This issue has bubbled up from time to time over the last 18 months or so (judging from my email archives).  It is not at all clear to me that there is indeed a consensus from deployments; some like it, some don't.

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2010-04-15 Thread Ed McNierney
Richard - I have a specific recollection of folks in Rwanda liking it. But my bigger concern is that we've shipped an awful lot of these with very few reported complaints. I just don't know what that means. It may well be that most folks don't like it, but I don't think we know. As they

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2010-04-15 Thread Sebastian Silva
Hi Ed, Our friends and volunteers Tuukka and Kaisa are currently in Pucallpa working with the teachers and kids. They probably havent seen this thread but this issue has popped up often here too and I wonder what you might think constitutes consensus from deployments. Also, the larger issue of

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2010-04-15 Thread Ed McNierney
Sebastian - No, you're quite right - it's hard. And it's hard to tell whether most users are silent because they're happy with it, or they're silent because they don't even realize that they have a choice. - Ed On Apr 15, 2010, at 11:42 AM, Sebastian Silva wrote: Hi Ed, Our

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2010-04-15 Thread Martin Langhoff
On Thu, Apr 15, 2010 at 12:35 PM, Richard Smith smithb...@gmail.com wrote: Who are the ones that like it?  I don't remember any good feedback. +1 m -- martin.langh...@gmail.com mar...@laptop.org -- School Server Architect - ask interesting questions - don't get distracted with shiny

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2010-04-15 Thread Ed McNierney
Tuukaa - I don't quite see how you can make statements like the OLPC project is not in close contact with the field. How do you know that? We *do* get many reports from deployment teams that represent hundreds of thousands of children, and try to collect and communicate that feedback

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2010-04-15 Thread Richard A. Smith
On 04/15/2010 01:52 PM, Ed McNierney wrote: We'd really like to see a *memo* about the *decision* that was made to change the default functioning of the touchpad to tap-to-click! Someone recognized the change in time, someone didn't assign enough importance to it to fix it in time. I did.

Re: illusion (Re: tap-to-click feedback)

2010-04-15 Thread Paul Fox
tuukka wrote: Further, the deployment teams *cannot* represent the children. They should strive to, but there is no substitute for going out on the field and seeing with your own trained eyes. while your point is well taken, the fact remains that no one but the deployment teams is in a

Re: illusion (Re: tap-to-click feedback)

2010-04-15 Thread Sebastian Silva
Hello OLPC! Glad to have your attention! Now while we do, it might be a good time to discuss ways to improve the way we can provide feedback. Please don't let our past and constant frustration with OLPC taint the very fact that we are volunteers trying to help OLPC's mission. It is no secret

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2010-04-15 Thread Tuukka Hastrup
Hi everyone, Ed McNierney escribió: No, you're quite right - it's hard. And it's hard to tell whether most users are silent because they're happy with it, or they're silent because they don't even realize that they have a choice. It's very easy to tell: the OLPC project is not in close

illusion (Re: tap-to-click feedback)

2010-04-15 Thread Tuukka Hastrup
Dear Edd, Ed McNierney escribió: Tuukaa - Thanks for your prompt reply, although it doesn't address the points of our report. We'd appreciate another one that did. Meanwhile, your reply demonstrates more general problems in the OLPC project, which would be worth solving as well. I don't

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2010-04-15 Thread C. Scott Ananian
Incidentally, I think it's important to distinguish between palm detection and tap to click. In my experience, most users who are used to tap to click, expect it -- and get frustrated when it doesn't work. On the other hand, I've been using a litl webbook with tap to click enabled since leaving

tap-to-click feedback

2009-10-22 Thread Daniel Drake
Just wanted to communicate an experience from the deployment here: A while back, we (OLPC + community) discussed the behaviour of the new XO touchpads which have tap-to-click on by default. We debated including the fairly large software changes to be able to disable this functionality with the

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2009-10-22 Thread James Cameron
I can only relate personal experience ... yes, it caught me by surprise quite a few times in the past few days. -- James Cameron http://quozl.linux.org.au/ ___ Devel mailing list Devel@lists.laptop.org http://lists.laptop.org/listinfo/devel

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2009-10-22 Thread Bert Freudenberg
On 22.10.2009, at 14:01, James Cameron wrote: I can only relate personal experience ... yes, it caught me by surprise quite a few times in the past few days. Me too - e.g., in TamTamMini it's easy to accidentally touch the pad while hammering on the keys. - Bert -

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2009-10-22 Thread Benjamin M. Schwartz
Daniel Drake wrote: Really I think the biggest issue is that they press it by accident while typing or making other motions and have no idea why the screen has changed significantly (they don't understand that it's because they clicked, or that their hand was near the pad). Normally,

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2009-10-22 Thread Martin Dengler
On Thu, Oct 22, 2009 at 02:40:04PM +0200, Bert Freudenberg wrote: On 22.10.2009, at 14:01, James Cameron wrote: I can only relate personal experience ... yes, it caught me by surprise quite a few times in the past few days. Me too - e.g., in TamTamMini it's easy to accidentally

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2009-10-22 Thread Paul Fox
benjamin m. schwartz wrote: Daniel Drake wrote: Really I think the biggest issue is that they press it by accident while typing or making other motions and have no idea why the screen has changed significantly (they don't understand that it's because they clicked, or that their hand

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2009-10-22 Thread Chris Ball
Hi, so: to eliminate tap-to-click, someone needs to build a new kernel with the synaptics driver enabled (maybe just the module can be built), then they need to figure out how to make it all work well. I might be wrong, but I think we just need the X driver -- yum install

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2009-10-22 Thread Daniel Drake
2009/10/22 Chris Ball c...@laptop.org: I might be wrong, but I think we just need the X driver -- yum install xorg-x11-drv-synaptics.  Xorg drivers are generally not layered on top of kernel drivers, outside of the case of DRI. Didn't work for me:

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2009-10-22 Thread John Gilmore
we tried the synaptics driver initially (when we got the new touchpads) but by itself it caused extremely erratic (perhaps not erratic, exactly, but just way-too-fast) mouse cursor behavior. There seems to be something wrong with general Linux mouse behavior. Even on ordinary optical mice

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2009-10-22 Thread Deepak Saxena
On Oct 22 2009, at 13:10, Chris Ball was caught saying: Hi, so: to eliminate tap-to-click, someone needs to build a new kernel with the synaptics driver enabled (maybe just the module can be built), then they need to figure out how to make it all work well. I might be

Re: tap-to-click feedback

2009-10-22 Thread James Cameron
On Thu, Oct 22, 2009 at 10:46:30AM -0700, John Gilmore wrote: There seems to be something wrong with general Linux mouse behavior. I felt this as well on Debian in the past few months ... I couldn't fix it easily, ended up disabling the new kernel based input feature. I *think* this is all I