Re: [OMPI devel] RFC: Add extra_state field to ompi_request_t

2009-12-11 Thread Jeff Squyres
We talked about this on the phone yesterday. Brian, Jeff, Terry, and Rolf were there. George was able to join for a short period of time. George's objections seemed to be twofold (please correct if wrong!): 1. Why not change all 3 function pointers to take an additional (void*)? George misun

Re: [OMPI devel] RFC: Add extra_state field to ompi_request_t

2009-11-29 Thread Barrett, Brian W
George -- Sure. Since I had talked to you and Jeff about it a year ago (when you added the callback) and you didn't complain, I assumed you two would be the only ones to care and wouldn't complain this time. Guess I should have known better :). Brian On 11/27/09 18:24 , "George Bosilca" wrot

Re: [OMPI devel] RFC: Add extra_state field to ompi_request_t

2009-11-27 Thread George Bosilca
Brian, This is a pretty big change to be done with a so short notice, especially over the Thanksgiving weekend. I do have a lots of concerns about this approach, but I lack the time to expand on this right now. I'll be back at work on Monday and I'll give detailed informations. Please delay the