Re: [OMPI devel] Question about new component submission

2025-01-22 Thread Howard Pritchard
Hello Florent, Would you be opening a PR for both PML and OSC components? The reason I ask is if you don’t have the OSC component ready to include in a PR how will you be supporting one sided ops? Would your PRs touch code outside of the new components? Also it would be nice to add some documen

[OMPI devel] Question about new component submission

2025-01-22 Thread 'Florent GERMAIN' via Open MPI devel
Hello, We are working on an external communication component. We plan to work on an open version of this external communication component to test it outside of our infrastructure. To use it with Open MPI, we developed a PML component (and are developing an OSC component). We would like to submit

Re: [OMPI devel] Question about new component submission

2025-01-22 Thread 'George Bosilca' via Open MPI devel
Florent, With such specific hardware needs the community would not be able to provide any guarantee (compile or test) about these component. Are you planning to join our github CI or at least the MTT tester in order to ensure correctness of the two proposed components ? Best, George. On Wed, Ja

RE: [OMPI devel] Question about new component submission

2025-01-22 Thread 'Florent GERMAIN' via Open MPI devel
The external communication component is named UBCL. It is the communication transport for our BXI interconnect for at least the coming years. It has a shared memory transport (for now CMA and CUDA IPC) and a BXI interconnect transport. Regards, Florent De : 'Jef

Re: [OMPI devel] Question about new component submission

2025-01-22 Thread 'Jeff Squyres (jsquyres)' via Open MPI devel
Additionally, we will want some assurances that you will continue to support the code over time. We are not looking for one-time dumps of software solely for the purpose of getting the code in the main community distribution. Can you give us a description of what these new PML and OSC component

Re: [OMPI devel] Question about new component submission

2025-01-22 Thread Gilles Gouaillardet
Florent, All you need is to issue a Pull Request and make sure the commits are signed off (and you understand the legal implications of doing that) Cheers, Gilles On Wed, Jan 22, 2025, 19:28 'Florent GERMAIN' via Open MPI devel < devel@lists.open-mpi.org> wrote: > Hello, > We are working on an

RE: [OMPI devel] Question about new component submission

2025-01-22 Thread 'Florent GERMAIN' via Open MPI devel
We plan to develop this year an open-source based transport (likely tcp) to allow UBCL to run on various machines. We need to check what is possible regarding CI and MTT on our side. Regards, Florent De : 'George Bosilca' via Open MPI devel Envoyé : mercredi 22