Re: [Discuss] unRAID

2011-07-31 Thread Tom Metro
Rich Braun wrote: > ...the unRAID sales pitch smacks of a solution in search of a problem. > > The built-in Linux RAID5 does it quite well for me, allowing mismatched > drives... > > With terabyte drives in the $50 price range, I can't see a situation > where kernel-based software RAID1 or RAID1

Re: [Discuss] unRAID

2011-07-26 Thread Tom Metro
[Forwarding on behalf of Rich Braun, whose list subscription needs adjustment, and apparently the list management UI isn't working yet. -Tom] Original Message Subject: Re: unRAID Date: Tue, 26 Jul 2011 15:04:43 + From: Rich Braun Edward Net Harvey opined: > But even losing

Re: [Discuss] unRAID

2011-07-26 Thread Bill Bogstad
On Tue, Jul 26, 2011 at 2:28 PM, Tom Metro wrote: > Bill Bogstad wrote: >> It also says that the individual data drives are formatted with >> ReiserFS. > > That doesn't bode well. Not exactly a popular choice these days, having > been mostly abandoned for ext3. Thanks for your clarifications and

Re: [Discuss] unRAID

2011-07-26 Thread Tom Metro
Bill Bogstad wrote: > It also says that the individual data drives are formatted with > ReiserFS. That doesn't bode well. Not exactly a popular choice these days, having been mostly abandoned for ext3. > A quick google search implies that the source code to their > changes are available, but its

Re: [Discuss] unRAID

2011-07-26 Thread Rich Braun
[resending, my first was blocked in moderator queue] Edward Net Harvey opined: > But even losing 5% of your > files is usually considered fatal, so that's why people usually adopt the > strategy of never losing more than their redundancy level, and make sure you > have backups. Indeed; the unRAID

Re: [Discuss] unRAID

2011-07-26 Thread Bill Bogstad
On Sun, Jul 24, 2011 at 2:39 PM, Tom Metro wrote: > While researching to buy/build an HTPC (likely to run XBMC) I ran across: > > > This is a good illustration of why we'd be better off getting > unRAID-like functionality added to a solid, widely used OS, like Linux > or FreeBSD. Though if yo

Re: [Discuss] unRAID

2011-07-26 Thread Edward Ned Harvey
> From: discuss-boun...@blu.org [mailto:discuss-boun...@blu.org] On Behalf > Of Tom Metro > > (ZFS pools are perhaps the closest approximation: > http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZFS#Storage_pools > but I don't think you can pull an arbitrary drive from a pool and > replace it with a higher capacity o

[Discuss] unRAID

2011-07-25 Thread Tom Metro
While researching to buy/build an HTPC (likely to run XBMC) I ran across: http://forum.xbmc.org/showthread.php?s=25935987f91ef317c33806af17e06e7a&t=94268 unRAID Advantages of Unraid -Allows you to mix and match drives of different sizes and makes into a single "User Share" of pooled sto