Re: [Discuss] unreadable sector

2013-10-13 Thread Jerry Feldman
On 10/12/2013 02:42 PM, Tom Metro wrote: Jerry Feldman wrote: ..would I be better served by removing this from the RAID pair, and run a full destructive bad block scan 'badblocks -wsv /dev/sda ... Yes. Even a non-destructive read-write scan (-n), followed by a RAID resync would do the trick

Re: [Discuss] unreadable sector

2013-10-13 Thread Tom Metro
Matthew Gillen wrote: Might be quicker to take the drive out of your RAID, attempt to write just to that block that you know is bad... Definitely quicker, but if you can live without the drive for a bit, better to do a full write test on the drive, because Ed might be right, and it could be an

Re: [Discuss] unreadable sector

2013-10-13 Thread Richard Pieri
Tom Metro wrote: Definitely quicker, but if you can live without the drive for a bit, better to do a full write test on the drive, because Ed might be right, and it could be an expanding problem. I'm with Ed. Any problem that isn't automatically corrected by a disk's on-board controller is

[Discuss] unreadable sector

2013-10-12 Thread Jerry Feldman
I've brought this up before. One of the drives in my RAID reports an unreadable sector. I'm not worried about thisas this otherwise seems to be a serviceable driveand I take frequent backups. One question I might have is would I be better served by removing this from the RAID pair, and run a full

Re: [Discuss] unreadable sector

2013-10-12 Thread Matthew Gillen
On 10/12/2013 8:06 AM, Jerry Feldman wrote: I've brought this up before. One of the drives in my RAID reports an unreadable sector. I'm not worried about thisas this otherwise seems to be a serviceable driveand I take frequent backups. One question I might have is would I be better served by

Re: [Discuss] unreadable sector

2013-10-12 Thread Daniel Feenberg
On Sat, 12 Oct 2013, Jerry Feldman wrote: I've brought this up before. One of the drives in my RAID reports an unreadable sector. I'm not worried about thisas this otherwise seems to be a serviceable driveand I take frequent backups. One question I might have is would I be better served by

Re: [Discuss] unreadable sector

2013-10-12 Thread Edward Ned Harvey (blu)
From: discuss-bounces+blu=nedharvey@blu.org [mailto:discuss- bounces+blu=nedharvey@blu.org] On Behalf Of Jerry Feldman I've brought this up before. One of the drives in my RAID reports an unreadable sector. I'm not worried about thisas this otherwise seems to be a serviceable

Re: [Discuss] unreadable sector

2013-10-12 Thread Edward Ned Harvey (blu)
Also, at the hardware level, invisible to the OS, drives reserve a certain number of blocks for transparent remapping. So if the number of bad blocks on your drive is higher than the number the drive can cover up... You might find that the specific addresses of bad blocks reported to your OS