[slim] Re: Backing up ripped music

2005-04-12 Thread John Stimson
My collection is currently 600 hours, and takes up 200 GB. It's all FLAC except for 4 songs in AAC. At 10MB/min (an approximation) for raw 16bit/44.1kSps audio, the FLAC is 55.4% as big as uncompressed WAV data would be. That's about what the FLAC website claims is typical... -- John

[slim] Re: Backing up ripped music

2005-04-10 Thread Mike Hanson
The cheapest and easiest method is with extra hard drives. You have two basic options for hosting the drive: - External USB2 enclosure for an 3.5 IDE drive. You can find these for $20-50US. - Removable trays, which you can get for around $15US (bay+tray), and additional trays cost

[slim] Re: Backing up ripped music

2005-04-10 Thread max . spicer
Manuel Rathmann Wrote: Well Max - this is what I am exactly trying to work out. The idea I had is to buy a Buffalo Linkstation. [...] Oh sorry, I've hijacked your thread in that case. I hadn't understood what a linkstation was - I assumed it was just another piece of network kit. Maybe I

[slim] Re: Backing up ripped music

2005-04-10 Thread max . spicer
How many FLAC albums do you get on a DVD on average? I keep meaning to compile some statistics on the average size of my compressed albums, but a quick scan shows they tend to be between 200-400MB. Nice and accurate! ;-) -- max.spicer The wild things roared their terrible roars and gnashed

[slim] Re: Backing up ripped music

2005-04-10 Thread DrRobert
I have been trying to deal with the backup issues as well. My problems is scale; I currently have about 24000 ripped flac tracks on hard disks which is about half of my cds. This is currently taking up a little over 1.0 TB on my linux box. Duping the drives would be painfully expensive. A

[slim] Re: Backing up ripped music

2005-04-10 Thread radish
robertwallace Wrote: I'm probably a bit old-fashioned. I tend to think of hard disks as production media not suitable to off-line long term storage. I'm sure that's no longer the case... Any way, when I ripped my CD collection for the 4th (and final time) -- to FLAC -- I backed up

Re: [slim] Re: Backing up ripped music

2005-04-10 Thread Robert Wallace
Oh, around 10 to 20 - Nice and accurate ;=) max.spicer wrote: How many FLAC albums do you get on a DVD on average? I keep meaning to compile some statistics on the average size of my compressed albums, but a quick scan shows they tend to be between 200-400MB. Nice and accurate! ;-)

[slim] Re: Backing up ripped music

2005-04-10 Thread healy
max.spicer Wrote: Manuel Rathmann wrote (in New Buffalo Linkstation and Slimserver): [..] my harddrive just went up in smoke - most probaply because I left it running for too long due to my Squeezebox. This sort of thing scares me a lot. I reckon I'll have spent 36 hours ripping all my

[slim] Re: Backing up ripped music

2005-04-10 Thread max . spicer
What flac options are you using? I think I'm using -6. -- max.spicer The wild things roared their terrible roars and gnashed their terrible teeth and rolled their terrible eyes and showed their terrible claws but Max stepped into his private boat and waved good-bye

[slim] Re: Backing up ripped music

2005-04-10 Thread radish
I keep meaning to compile some statistics on the average size of my compressed albums, but a quick scan shows they tend to be between 200-400MB Wow. Mine average 500, I must have some kind of broken FLAC codec ;) More seriously, I think it must have to do with the type of music. I always see

RE: [slim] Re: Backing up ripped music

2005-04-10 Thread Phillip Kerman
DVDs are not exactly archival. Naturally, hard drives have the issue that your OS may not support the HD in the future. I often feel like a dung beetle copying all my stuff from computer to computer. Anyway, I just use HDs. Thanks, Phillip ___

Re: [slim] Re: Backing up ripped music

2005-04-10 Thread jan van mourik
I used this in EAC (compression options - External Compression - Additional command line options): -6 --replay-gain -V -T artist=%a -T title=%t -T album=%g -T date=%y -T tracknumber=%n -T genre=%m -T comment=EAC 0.95prebeta5 / FLAC 1.1.0 %s And as an example these are the sizes for Steely Dan

RE: [slim] Re: Backing up ripped music

2005-04-10 Thread Phillip Kerman
Shoot, most of my 5.25 disks that had sat in a box for 10 years worked the last time I went through them before their ultimate disposal. I think that magnetic media--although it's sensitive to fields--is notably better for long-term archiving. I believe CDs are estimated at about 10 years

Re: [slim] Re: Backing up ripped music

2005-04-10 Thread Jeff Coffler
From: radish [EMAIL PROTECTED] I keep meaning to compile some statistics on the average size of my compressed albums, but a quick scan shows they tend to be between 200-400MB Wow. Mine average 500, I must have some kind of broken FLAC codec ;) Mine are much shorter as well. Here's a short sample:

Re: [slim] Re: Backing up ripped music

2005-04-10 Thread Robert Wallace
I have a lot of CDs that were originally released on vinyl. That limits them, in most cases, to 25-40 minutes in length. Considering the rule-of-thumb of a bit over 10 MB / minute of audio, uncompressed and approx 50% compression with FLAC, I generally get 200 - 250 MB (in FLAC) for a 30

Re: [slim] Re: Backing up ripped music

2005-04-10 Thread Mark Bennett
Well for single albums, mine seem to vary between pretty small and very large: 164M/media2/Flac/Enya/Watermark to 689M/media2/Flac/Fish/Mixed Company (This CD is so long that I can't rip the last track, and I've tried 4 different DVD drives on Linux and Windows... It's also a live

[slim] Re: Backing up ripped music

2005-04-10 Thread radish
Well, yes, most of my albums are full, i.e. 72 mins, which will make them larger than 40-45 mins pop albums. But, I'm still not seeing the ratios. For example, I took a random selection of 4 tracks from an album, and compared them at different settings: 4 tracks, total play time 16:06 WAV: