Re: PPIG discuss: How hard is programming?

2001-05-03 Thread Alan Blackwell
Ruven said: There's one slight flaw in Alan's argument. What I said was: Both of these cases also illustrate that substantial amounts of programming knowledge is above the level of the individual programming language constructs. This knowledge is NOT general engineering knowledge,

RE: PPIG discuss: How hard is programming?

2001-05-03 Thread Brooks, Ruven
Alan, You stated: I believe that the academic establishment rapidly expands to fill gaps in the research ecosystem. If there was any real need for the psychology of automobile body welding, someone would be doing it. Let me assure that you are dead, 100% wrong. There are a great many

Re: PPIG discuss: How hard is programming?

2001-05-02 Thread Derek M Jones
Ruven, First, let me note that even a factor of 4-5 for differences in programmer performance is already substantially greater than almost any other human skill. If one choose a sample of first year college students at the same university, one would be unlikely to uncover a difference that

RE: PPIG discuss: How hard is programming?

2001-05-02 Thread Brooks, Ruven
There's one slight flaw in Alan's argument. What I said was: Both of these cases also illustrate that substantial amounts of programming knowledge is above the level of the individual programming language constructs. This knowledge is NOT general engineering knowledge, project management