Re: PPIG discuss: the believability of scientific proof

2001-10-02 Thread Alan Blackwell
If they did not know the context would the members of this list think that the following sounded reasonable? http://www.aulterra-uk.com/new_page_2.htm The initial results sounded to me as though a barely-relevant experiment was being used to support a marginal product aimed at a market

Re: PPIG discuss: the believability of scientific proof

2001-10-02 Thread Derek M Jones
Alan, The initial results sounded to me as though a barely-relevant experiment ... There is a thread of reasoning in the argument. It is just your practiced eye at finding the weak links in arguments that prevented you from seeing it. This kind of thing is very common out there in the big