Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread Russell Keith-Magee
On 10/1/07, Stefan Matthias Aust <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > There are still 12 tickets from the last sprint (great effort, BTW) > left to check-in. The casual observer easily gets the impression that > work is sporadic, uncoordinated and not target-oriented, in one word: > chaotic. Yes, of co

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread Mark Green
On Mon, 2007-10-01 at 17:07 +0200, Stefan Matthias Aust wrote: > Joe, > > 2007/10/1, Joe <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > > [...] > > And this is the biggest disconnect between Django's team and the > > business world. If I went to my bosses and told them "It's done when > > it's done" about our upcoming

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread Malcolm Tredinnick
On Mon, 2007-10-01 at 12:18 -0700, Joe wrote: [...] > Are you sure there is no compromise on doing a "stable" tag every few > months? Unless you religiously monitor the timelines and the google > groups, it is a little difficult to pick a good time to tag the trunk > between major merges and refac

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread Joe
Derek, I agree with you that the waterfall method of software development is broken and we don't use it here. However, we do set deadlines and goals, and we try to make them an accurate estimation of time required to complete work. How do we do this? Using a lot of the techniques that you said

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread Joe
Malcolm, I may not agree with everything you said, but I appreciate you taking the time to write a response and address my concerns in a logical, thoughtful manner . Are you sure there is no compromise on doing a "stable" tag every few months? Unless you religiously monitor the timelines and the

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread Derek Anderson
actually, "it's done when it's done" can be sold in a corporate environment. it has the unfortunate characteristic of being the closest thing to truth when modeling software development, and no amount of pre-planning or chart-making is going to get you a more accurate answer. some key facts t

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread [EMAIL PROTECTED]
How about a management FAQ? And then... (you'll hate this): For each answer which is emotionally unsatisfying, what are the smallest changes you could make which would allow you to tweak the answer to be more satisfying? For example: A simple, pretty, easily accessible page that allows voting on

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread staff-gmail
okay,okay, I'll just write up something and submit it :) I didn't see any welcome or about page on the main site so I'll work on that and include this stuff. Now back to coding. Tim Chase wrote: >> similar - sooo, do you think it's worthwhile to pull this together on a >> about / welcome /

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread Henning Hraban Ramm
Am 2007-10-01 um 18:46 schrieb Tim Chase: >> similar - sooo, do you think it's worthwhile to pull this together >> on a >> about / welcome / introduction page under a heading like "How Django >> Works". Then when these comments come, they can be pointed to the >> page. If you think it's worthw

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread Marty Alchin
On 10/1/07, Malcolm Tredinnick <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Maintaining information in more than one place is a burden. We are all > volunteers. Ergo, we try to keep the effort required to maintain stuff > to a minimum. The reason I made the point that all of this information > is available via Go

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread Tim Chase
> similar - sooo, do you think it's worthwhile to pull this together on a > about / welcome / introduction page under a heading like "How Django > Works". Then when these comments come, they can be pointed to the > page. If you think it's worthwhile, I'll post some text to a > documentation

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread staff-gmail
Malcolm, well said - I just wasted a bunch of time writing a response that was similar - sooo, do you think it's worthwhile to pull this together on a about / welcome / introduction page under a heading like "How Django Works". Then when these comments come, they can be pointed to the page.

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread Malcolm Tredinnick
On Mon, 2007-10-01 at 17:36 +0200, Stefan Matthias Aust wrote: [...] > I'd like to reword (and overstate) your statement: "If you're too lazy > to search for the existing information yourself, you're not worth it." > Is that correct? Of course not. Please stop trying to inflame the conversation i

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread Malcolm Tredinnick
On Mon, 2007-10-01 at 06:05 -0700, Joe wrote: > > I'll pause for a moment here and step out of responding as a Django > > user, and step into responding as Django's release manager: the answer > > is "when it's ready". If you have a foolproof way of figuring out when > > that will be, you should s

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread Stefan Matthias Aust
2007/10/1, Malcolm Tredinnick <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > Of course, lower priority issues are going to languish a bit longer than > more pressing needs. Somebody who wants to count open tickets instead of > looking a bit deeper isn't going to like that, but since we're not > catering to that audience

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread Stefan Matthias Aust
James, 2007/10/1, James Bennett <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > Not having copious documentation of everything the dev team is doing > isn't the same as "making it a secret" ;) I believe in "clarification by overstatement" :) > Again, the easy way to see what's going on is to watch the Trac > timeline

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread Stefan Matthias Aust
Joe, 2007/10/1, Joe <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > [...] > And this is the biggest disconnect between Django's team and the > business world. If I went to my bosses and told them "It's done when > it's done" about our upcoming product releases, I would get fired. > Your response should be, "It's really

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread Malcolm Tredinnick
On Mon, 2007-10-01 at 14:21 +0200, Stefan Matthias Aust wrote: > James, > > thanks for your details answer. Let me put it right here: I'm not > complaining about the lack of dedication or progress in the > development of Django. It's more about visibility and marketing. > > 2007/10/1, James Benn

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread James Bennett
On 10/1/07, Stefan Matthias Aust <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > It might be very obvious to you what is missing before 0.97 can be > released because you're deeply involved with the development and > exactly know it. However, I cannot easily find the answer on the web > site. Searching the mailing a

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread Joe
> I'll pause for a moment here and step out of responding as a Django > user, and step into responding as Django's release manager: the answer > is "when it's ready". If you have a foolproof way of figuring out when > that will be, you should stop writing code and start making millions > of dollar

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread Stefan Matthias Aust
James, thanks for your details answer. Let me put it right here: I'm not complaining about the lack of dedication or progress in the development of Django. It's more about visibility and marketing. 2007/10/1, James Bennett <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > On 10/1/07, Stefan Matthias Aust <[EMAIL PROTECTE

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread Jon Atkinson
> > > The documentation clearly advertises the current trunk > > version, but the book refers to 0.96. The django book project seems to > > have died in Feb. The site does not explain why the missing chapters > > where never written/published and what the current state is. > > The book isn't dead,

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread James Bennett
On 10/1/07, Stefan Matthias Aust <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > There's no 0.97 version despites all that changes to SVN trunk for > months. Because we're not ready for a 0.97 release. The goals for the next release and the general run up to Django 1.0 are pretty well-known, even if they're not met

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread cschand
Stefan's observations have very interesting points. I am also looking forwad to replies cschand --~--~-~--~~~---~--~~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Django users" group. To post to this group, send email to django-use

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread Ramdas S
Interesting observations. I like the idea of a road map. But we do not have any full time people working on Django. May be we can look at incrementing the version by 0.01every 500 SVN commits or so. RS On 10/1/07, Stefan Matthias Aust <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > Over the last few weeks, w

Re: Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread Jon Atkinson
There are some interesting points here, I look forward to the replies. --Jon On 10/1/07, Stefan Matthias Aust <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Over the last few weeks, we used Django to successfully create > prototype applications and it just worked great (well, large file > upload is broken, I ha

Should Django have a road map?

2007-10-01 Thread Stefan Matthias Aust
Over the last few weeks, we used Django to successfully create prototype applications and it just worked great (well, large file upload is broken, I had to patch our Django version with #2070 a couple of times). What a relieve compared to Java web development! A big "thank you" to all developers a