With this comment, we see the pernicious effect of using a binary psd=(y|n)
token to represent a multi-valued role.When the role indicator is
missing, there is no default value, instead it must be inferred from the
context.Since the author of the proposed text is confused on this
point, it
In the general case, we allow for this possible configuration:
public suffix domain segments
organization domain for public registration organization
subdomains of the organization
registration point for private registration clients
organization domain for private registration clients
sub
It appears that Murray S. Kucherawy said:
>The status we're going for is "Proposed Standard". Note the word
>"Proposed"; a document seeking this status doesn't need to be bulletproof ...
I would expect a great deal of institutional pushback at a change directly
from informational to full standa
Sigh...
On Thu, Mar 17, 2022 at 2:50 PM Murray S. Kucherawy
wrote:
> The status we're going for is "Proposed Standard". Note the word
> "Proposed"; a document seeking this status doesn't need to be bulletproof
> out the door, as some evolution based on experience is required. The
> standard fo
On Thu, Mar 17, 2022 at 1:13 PM Dotzero wrote:
> My understanding when the DMARCbis effort was spun up was that we were
> trying to move it to Standard Track. Is this still the goal? A number of
> experimental things are currently being included. This would seem to
> preclude DMARC being on Stand
My understanding when the DMARCbis effort was spun up was that we were
trying to move it to Standard Track. Is this still the goal? A number of
experimental things are currently being included. This would seem to
preclude DMARC being on Standard Track.
If the experimental items being discussed wer
It appears that Alessandro Vesely said:
>> To find the org domain for a domain:
>>chop the domain to the last five labels and walk up the tree.
>>stop when you find a DMARC record with psd or you hit the root.
>>if a record has psd=n, that's the org domain
>>if a record has psd=y
On Wed, Mar 16, 2022 at 11:27 PM Scott Kitterman
wrote:
>
>
> I'll take another shot at it, but I'm unlikely to finish it tonight.
>
>
I've been working to incorporate the proposed text that Scott submitted the
other day, and following along with the discussion since, and I think I've
got a new d
On Wed 16/Mar/2022 03:10:03 +0100 Douglas Foster wrote:
I started from the assumption that we would want to generalize NP into
organizations. But after spending a lot of time on the subject for the last
15 months, I am convinced that it is not needed.
Assume that a university or other organi
On Thu 17/Mar/2022 04:02:00 +0100 John Levine wrote:
It appears that Scott Kitterman said:
It took a fair amount of editing and I expect you all will have further
suggestions, so instead of getting up to my elbows in XML, I took the
published DMARCbis-05 text and updated it directly. The mod
10 matches
Mail list logo
