When a topic is decided with consensus, it does not get reopened.What
happened here?
On Sun, Jul 24, 2022, 9:35 PM John R Levine wrote:
> >> I hope you agree that .com is a domain. The spec says that in order to
> >> discover the Organizational Domain for a domain, I can perform the DNS
>
I hope you agree that .com is a domain. The spec says that in order to
discover the Organizational Domain for a domain, I can perform the DNS Tree
Walk as needed for any of the domains in question. That way, the domain in
question, .com, is the Organizational Domain of itself. That is wrong
On July 24, 2022 9:58:46 AM UTC, Alessandro Vesely wrote:
>John,
>
>On Sat 23/Jul/2022 19:52:33 +0200 John Levine wrote:
>> As I would hope everyone in this discussion would be aware, the "as if"
>> rule applies to all IETF standards. You can do whatever you want so long
>> as the result is
Ale's point is part of a larger inefficiency. As information is gathered,
the candidate names can be reviewed for a match. If a match is obtained,
the result is PASS and the algorithm exits. If not, then candidate names
which can be ruled out are discarded. If this makes the candidate list
Count| Bytes | Who
++---
44 ( 100%) | 275972 ( 100%) | Total
14 (31.8%) | 85847 (31.1%) | Scott Kitterman
13 (29.5%) | 71816 (26.0%) | Alessandro Vesely
8 (18.2%) | 40989 (14.9%) | John Levine
4 ( 9.1%) | 43642 (15.8%) | Douglas Foster
John,
On Sat 23/Jul/2022 19:52:33 +0200 John Levine wrote:
As I would hope everyone in this discussion would be aware, the "as if"
rule applies to all IETF standards. You can do whatever you want so long
as the result is the same as if you had done what the spec says.
The "as if" rule also
