Re: [dmarc-discuss] DMARC authentication issues with Google

2017-12-12 Thread Brandon Long via dmarc-discuss
There are multiple services, such as Valimail or Dmarcian or whatever which can help you make that decision, though perhaps they're all a bit biased towards actually making the transition to quarantine/reject. It may be possible to switch to quarantine until the blast is contained. You do have

Re: [dmarc-discuss] DMARC authentication issues with Google

2017-10-05 Thread Brandon Long via dmarc-discuss
That graph is awful, especially how it's conflating those three things. My guess (I don't know much about the postmaster tools), is that SPF is only judging what has an envelope sender for your domain, DKIM is only judging what has a DKIM signature, and DMARC is judging what is "From" your

Re: [dmarc-discuss] DMARC authentication issues with Google

2017-10-05 Thread Roland Turner via dmarc-discuss
Is the information in this graph consistent with what's in Google's aggregate feedback? (This is to determine whether Google's DMARC implementation is broken, or just the postmaster tool.) - Roland On 05/10/17 18:51, The Venus Project Postmaster via dmarc-discuss wrote: Hi everyone, For

[dmarc-discuss] DMARC authentication issues with Google

2017-10-05 Thread The Venus Project Postmaster via dmarc-discuss
Hi everyone, For the past several months we have been experiencing ups and downs in our DMARC authentication with Gmail, as seen from Google's postmaster tool (see attached screenshot). DKIM and SPF authentication are consistently at 100%, but DMARC authentication varies wildly, although