Re: [dmarc-discuss] please clarify

2016-04-05 Thread A. Schulze via dmarc-discuss
Roland Turner via dmarc-discuss: That question has rather a large answer, parts of which span a decade of work on email authentication. It might perhaps be simpler to address the situation that's concerning you. Are you facing a specific situation for which this creates a problem?

Re: [dmarc-discuss] please clarify

2016-04-05 Thread Roland Turner via dmarc-discuss
Andreas Schulze wrote: > Roland Turner via dmarc-discuss: > >> Yes. In all of the cases above, the Organizational Domain for both >> RFC5322.From and the DKIM/SPF authentication is example.com, >> consequently they match in relaxed mode. The same would be true for: >> >> - RFC5322.From:

Re: [dmarc-discuss] please clarify

2016-04-05 Thread Roland Turner via dmarc-discuss
Andreas Schulze wrote: > Roland Turner via dmarc-discuss: > >> Yes. In all of the cases above, the Organizational Domain for both >> RFC5322.From and the DKIM/SPF authentication is example.com, >> consequently they match in relaxed mode. The same would be true for: >> >> - RFC5322.From:

Re: [dmarc-discuss] please clarify

2016-04-05 Thread A. Schulze via dmarc-discuss
Roland Turner via dmarc-discuss: Yes. In all of the cases above, the Organizational Domain for both RFC5322.From and the DKIM/SPF authentication is example.com, consequently they match in relaxed mode. The same would be true for: - RFC5322.From: a.example.com - DKIM or SPF authentication

Re: [dmarc-discuss] please clarify

2016-04-05 Thread Roland Turner via dmarc-discuss
A. Schulze wrote: > I have a question about DMARC alignments. > > the usual case: > - RFC5322.From: sub.example.com > - DKIM or SPF authentication identifier: example.com > > -> this is aligned in relax mode. > > But: > - RFC5322.From: example.com > - DKIM or SPF authentication identifier:

[dmarc-discuss] please clarify

2016-04-05 Thread A. Schulze via dmarc-discuss
Hello, I have a question about DMARC alignments. the usual case: - RFC5322.From: sub.example.com - DKIM or SPF authentication identifier: example.com -> this is aligned in relax mode. But: - RFC5322.From: example.com - DKIM or SPF authentication identifier: sub.example.com Is this a