[DNSOP] Comments on draft-dnsop-deleg-00.txt - Section 3

2024-01-25 Thread Edward Lewis
# 3. Implementation ... # 3.1. Including DELEG RRs in a Zone # #A DELEG RRset MAY be present at a delegation point. The DELEG RRset #MAY contain multiple records. DELEG RRsets MUST NOT appear at a #zone's apex. # #A DELEG RRset MAY be present with or without NS or DS RRsets

[DNSOP] Comments on draft-dnsop-deleg-00.txt - section 2

2024-01-25 Thread Edward Lewis
As I'm not writing code, my comments will be less detailed... # 2. DELEG Record Type ... # 2.1. Difference between the records # #This document uses two different resource record types. Both records #have the same functionality, with the difference between them being #that the

[DNSOP] Comments on draft-dnsop-deleg-00.txt - section 1

2024-01-25 Thread Edward Lewis
I won't be pedantic (nits, wording) this time around, just raise conceptual issues in section 1 # 1. Introduction # #In the Domain Name System [STD13], subdomains within the domain name #hierarchy are indicated by delegations to servers which are #authoritative for their portion of

[DNSOP] Comments on draft-dnsop-deleg-00.txt - abstract

2024-01-25 Thread Edward Lewis
Being clear on the motivation for taking on the development and eventual deployment of DELEG is important to carry this work forward. I'll start with some pedantic observations about the abstract: #Abstract # # A delegation in the Domain Name System (DNS) is a mechanism that # enables

Re: [DNSOP] Followup Working Group Last Call for draft-ietf-dnsop-dnssec-bootstrapping

2024-01-25 Thread Christian Elmerot
Hi everyone! I support the publication of this document. Regards, Christian On 2024-01-21 00:23, Tim Wicinski wrote: All Peter has integrated feedback from the first working group last call, and we'd like to do a followup last call.  The diff with the current version is here: