Re: [ECOLOG-L] Is academic publishing a racket? Yes

2011-09-06 Thread malcolm McCallum
ON a related thread. Lawrence 2007. The mismeasurement of science. Current Biology http://www.labri.fr/perso/gimbert/lawrence-current-biology-2007.pdf Excerpt: Answer from the hero in Leo Szilard’s 1948 story “The Mark Gable Foundation” when asked by a wealthy entrepreneur who believes that scien

Re: [ECOLOG-L] Is academic publishing a racket? Yes

2011-09-06 Thread David L. McNeely
"Alexandre F. Souza" wrote: > Dear Julie, (stuff cut out) > I am also not a fan of high-impact journals. In a web era like ours, > articles are searched for easily and most people tends to pick them > according to affinity to current interests and not so much by the > "importance" of t

[ECOLOG-L] Is academic publishing a racket? Yes

2011-09-05 Thread Alexandre F. Souza
Dear Julie, I fully agree with Monbiot's criticism of scientific publishing by academic publishers and believe it is far from paranoia. The main scape out are the open journals. For many of us third world researchers the main difficulty regarding open journals are page charges. I believe it