Re: [ECOLOG-L] Taxonomy and Ecology Integrating or Disintegrating?

2010-11-13 Thread Warren W. Aney
After spending many years afield with interdisciplinary teams, I concluded that geologists/soil scientists spend their time looking at the ground, botanists/silviculturists spend their time looking at the plants and trees; zoologists/wildlife biologists spend their time looking through the plants

Re: [ECOLOG-L] Taxonomy and Ecology Integrating or Disintegrating?

2010-11-13 Thread Bill Silvert
Wayne's story reminds me that the eminent ecologist Larry Slobodkin once observed that ecology without species is the ultimate abomination. I was giving some lectures on size-structured ecosystems, so I introduced myself as an abominable ecologist. It seemed a fitting title. Still does. Bill

[ECOLOG-L] Kathryn Fuller Science for Nature Fellowships

2010-11-13 Thread David Inouye
Dear Colleagues: World Wildlife Fund is announcing the 2011 Kathryn Fuller Science for Nature Fellowships to support doctoral and postdoctoral research on marine protected areas (MPAs) that shows promise to enhance scientific understanding of their ecological and social impacts and that will

Re: [ECOLOG-L] Taxonomy and Ecology Integrating or Disintegrating?

2010-11-13 Thread Wayne Tyson
Bill's story reminds me of the time Karen Sausman asked, What is a species? It seems to be all in a flux, what with PhD candidates swarming all over the herbaria changing names and such, but not re-inventing the whole basis for nomenclature (at least). Maybe the geneticists will clear it all

Re: [ECOLOG-L] Taxonomy and Ecology Integrating or Disintegrating?

2010-11-13 Thread Charles Stephen
Why would he care about compiling a checklist of a region if he was not interested in geographical patterns of species distributions? If it's pure nomenclature that he cares about, surely teaching-quality samples with no locality info would suffice. For that matter, why bother looking at real

Re: [ECOLOG-L] Taxonomy and Ecology Integrating or Disintegrating?

2010-11-13 Thread Wayne Tyson
I could only take this person's word for it. The interpretation I came away with was that it was something akin to stamp collecting, but I suspect that part of the story might be that taxonomy is taxing enough in itself without being overly concerned with ecology and evolution. It was the