[ECOLOG-L] New Snake Field Guide - Panama

2015-03-28 Thread Dr. Julie M. Ray, La MICA Biological Station
Panama, with its high diversity of snakes and high number of venomous snakebites each year (thus resulting in many intentional snake killings as well) still lacks a comprehensive field guide for residents, tourists, and researchers.Team Snake Panama is working to change that.Please check out our

Re: [ECOLOG-L] publication by scientific societies

2015-03-28 Thread Martin Meiss
Hi David Inouye, Several times in recent years there have been lengthy threads on Ecolog discussing the fact that many scientific publications are prohibitively expensive for scholars working in poor countries or who are affiliated with institutions with very limited resources. This seems to h

Re: [ECOLOG-L] fabricated reviews lead to retractions of papers

2015-03-28 Thread Stephen L. Young
It is interesting that we tend to look at how things were and reminisce about how good it was then, yet I wonder if we were thinking similarly at that time? The same things have been said regarding formula funding and IDC rates and while comparison with the past is good, there needs to be a balance

Re: [ECOLOG-L] fabricated reviews lead to retractions of papers

2015-03-28 Thread David Duffy
In business, since the Industrial Revolution, there has been a saying that you can have two out of three: Fast, Cheap, or Good. American society has gone with fast and cheap, and science publishing has been dragged into the same choice of values. I doubt this is good for science or society in the l

Re: [ECOLOG-L] fabricated reviews lead to retractions of papers

2015-03-28 Thread Martin Meiss
Hi, Malcolm, I read your entire post, and found it quite moving. I don't know how to estimate or balance the human cost involved, but I'd hold it up as better way to achieve scientific excellence and integrity than the slick procedures of for-profit scientific publishing. Martin 2015-03-28 12

Re: [ECOLOG-L] fabricated reviews lead to retractions of papers

2015-03-28 Thread Malcolm McCallum
Herpetological Conservation and Biology is still published by researchers without a publishing house. There is a very good reason you don't see this much anymore, and it is not cost. . If the journal is run as an online outfit, keeping its presence on the web can move forward for as little as $5 a

Re: [ECOLOG-L] fabricated reviews lead to retractions of papers

2015-03-28 Thread Malcolm McCallum
I don't know, I enjoy doing peer reviews. But, I don't treat peer review like editing a journal. If the paper is ripe with bad writing, I might correct a paragraph and tell them to do the whole paper. Mostly, I dwell on did they miss citations, cover the literature, approach the problem properly

Re: [ECOLOG-L] publication by scientific societies

2015-03-28 Thread David S Schimel
and in Ecological Applications, the January issue. Dave Schimel On Mar 28, 2015, at 10:05 AM, David Inouye wrote: > The Ecological Society of America, which has self-published its journals for > about a century, is facing this kind of issue Martin raises below. Most of > the societies that p

Re: [ECOLOG-L] publication by scientific societies

2015-03-28 Thread David Inouye
The Ecological Society of America, which has self-published its journals for about a century, is facing this kind of issue Martin raises below. Most of the societies that publish journals read by ecologists have already moved to partner with some of the large publishers (Wiley, Elsevier, Oxford

Re: [ECOLOG-L] fabricated reviews lead to retractions of papers

2015-03-28 Thread Martin Meiss
I'm till wondering about the fact that one financial interest controls (in some ways at least) 277 journals. Does each of those journals have independent editors? Is some bureaucrat assigning "peer" reviewers to journals whose subject matter is utterly unknown to him/her? Is it handled the way D

[ECOLOG-L] SCCS-Bengaluru 2015: Abstract submission deadline extended to April 10, 2015

2015-03-28 Thread Devathi Parashuram
Dear all, Please note that the deadline for abstraction submissions for the Student Conference on Conservation Science-Bengaluru 2015 has been extended to 23:59 (Indian Standard Time) on *April 10th*. The conference aims to attract young researchers and students all over the world (and especially