Re: [ECOLOG-L] Hypothesis Testing in Ecology: Precision is what makes it valuable

2011-03-11 Thread Paul Grogan
Hi Kevin, this is great. Here's a link to a PDF of the article I wrote in the British Ecological Society journal http://post.queensu.ca/~groganp/Hypotheses%20in%20Ecology2foradobe.pdf. Figure 1 in particular may help in making more clear what I mean by iterative, and how one cycle feeds into

Re: [ECOLOG-L] Hypothesis Testing in Ecology: Precision is what makes it valuable

2011-03-10 Thread Wayne Tyson
Honorable Ecolog Forum: At the risk of repeating and repeating myself, I am once again going to cast my good sense and caution to the winds and confess that I have operated most of my life on the proposition that one (I) must go with the roughest guess that gets the job done (is demonstrably

Re: [ECOLOG-L] Hypothesis Testing in Ecology: Precision is what makes it valuable

2011-03-09 Thread Paul Grogan
Hi, I am fascinated by the varying use of hypotheses in ecology, and have been following the recent emails with great interest. All scientific research must presumably share a common goal to reach the highest attainable levels of precision in explicitly articulating the research focus, and the

Re: [ECOLOG-L] Hypothesis Testing in Ecology: Precision is what makes it valuable

2011-03-09 Thread Martin Meiss
Paul Grogan has stated very elegantly the case for a well formulated hypothesis, but I wish point out another aspect of the matter. People who are prospecting for iron will pass right over gold without seeing it. This is more than just a metaphor; it reflects how the human mind seems to work.