Re: When one should stop sampling?

2001-11-13 Thread Donald Burrill
On 12 Nov 2001, Niko Tiliopoulos wrote: I am acting as the stats advisor for my unit in the psychology department of the University of Edinburgh, UK. Last week a colleague of mine presented me with the following issue, and I am not quite sure how to respond: She is running a

Re: Evaluating students

2001-11-13 Thread Herman Rubin
In article [EMAIL PROTECTED], Stan Brown [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: John Kane [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote in sci.stat.edu: . I don't think I ever said the answer is not important; if I did say so I didn't mean to. The right answer is important, but after all

Re: Evaluating students

2001-11-13 Thread Herman Rubin
In article [EMAIL PROTECTED], Thom Baguley [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Glen wrote: As a student I *always* preferred closed book exams. If I know the material I don't need the book, and if I don't know the material, the book isn't going to help in the exam enough anyway. For open Yes. Also,

Re: Evaluating students

2001-11-13 Thread Jerry Dallal
John Kane wrote: Very true and I was being deliberatly provocative. Howeever I still cannot see penalizing someone for gerttaingt the right anwser no matter how arried at. Problem: Divide 95 by 19. Student writes 95/19, 9's cancel, leaving 5/1 = 5 . How much credit do you award?

Re: Good Book on Clustering Algorithm??

2001-11-13 Thread John Uebersax
Chia C Chong [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote in message news:9sk4p9$1e9$[EMAIL PROTECTED]... Any recommendation for books on Clustering Algorithm?? Two suggestions: Anderberg, M.R. (1973), Cluster Analysis for Applications, New York: Academic Press, Inc. Hartigan, J.A. (1975),

regression on timeseries data: differencing ?

2001-11-13 Thread Eric Duton
Dear all, When applying multiple regression on timeseries data, should I check (similarly to ARIMA-models) for unit roots in the dependent variable and the predictor variables and perform the necessary differencing OR could I simply start the multiple regression analysis on the pure timeseries

regression on timeseries data: differencing ?

2001-11-13 Thread Eric Duton
Dear all, When applying multiple regression on timeseries data, should I check (similarly to ARIMA-models) for unit roots in the dependent variable and the predictor variables and perform the necessary differencing OR could I simply start the multiple regression analysis on the pure timeseries

regression on timeseries data: differencing ?

2001-11-13 Thread Eric Duton
Dear all, When applying multiple regression on timeseries data, should I check (similarly to ARIMA-models) for unit roots in the dependent variable and the predictor variables and perform the necessary differencing OR could I simply start the multiple regression analysis on the pure timeseries

Re: Evaluating students

2001-11-13 Thread Alan McLean
Herman Rubin wrote: In article [EMAIL PROTECTED], Thom Baguley [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Glen wrote: As a student I *always* preferred closed book exams. If I know the material I don't need the book, and if I don't know the material, the book isn't going to help in the exam enough

Re: Fw: We need your help!!!

2001-11-13 Thread Rich Ulrich
On 12 Nov 2001 11:41:45 -0800, [EMAIL PROTECTED] (Carl Huberty) wrote: It would be greatly appreciated if I could get references for the six topics mentioned in the message below. I assume that Conover (1999) discusses the first topic. But beyond that I am at a loss. Thanks in advance.

Re: When one should stop sampling?

2001-11-13 Thread Niko Tiliopoulos
Dear all, In light of the very interesting and highly appreciated response I received in my mailbox, allow me to attempt to be more clear. First I should say that I am not aware of the deep details of the study (it is indeed someone else's and I am not trying to cover up my errors). Ss are put

Re: regression on timeseries data: differencing ?

2001-11-13 Thread Donald Burrill
On Tue, 13 Nov 2001, Wendy (alias Eric Duton?) wrote: When applying multiple regression on timeseries data, should I check (similarly to ARIMA-models) for unit roots in the dependent variable and the predictor variables and perform the necessary differencing OR could I simply start

Re: Evaluating students

2001-11-13 Thread Donald Burrill
On Wed, 14 Nov 2001, Alan McLean wrote in part: Herman Rubin wrote: A good exam would be one which someone who has merely memorized the book would fail, and one who understands the concepts but has forgotten all the formulas would do extremely well on. Since to understand the

Re: Evaluating students

2001-11-13 Thread Carl Lee
Using introductory statistics as an example, concepts are built in a certain sequence. If students get lost at a certain stage, s/he will have difficulty to connect the later concepts together. Therefore, it is crucial to test the understanding of the connection (or relationship) among related

Re: Evaluating students

2001-11-13 Thread Alan McLean
Students also confuse histograms with time series graphs. They describe a graph as, for example, 'starting low, increasing then decreasing again'. It's easy enough to see how they get this approach from their school maths. It's much more difficult to get them to see a histogram as rather more