Re: Most Common Mistake In Statistical Inference

2001-03-24 Thread Herman Rubin
In article [EMAIL PROTECTED], Robert J. MacG. Dawson [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: "W. D. Allen Sr." wrote: A common mistake made in statistical inference is to assume every data set is normally distributed. This seems to be the rule rather than the exception, even among professional

Re: Most Common Mistake In Statistical Inference

2001-03-22 Thread Bob Hayden
Re assumptions for inference... - Forwarded message from Robert J. MacG. Dawson - What is needed in the small-sample case is outside _knowledge_ (not "well, it _might_ be true" or "in this discipline we usually assume..." assumptions!) about the distribution - without this we should not

Re: Most Common Mistake In Statistical Inference

2001-03-22 Thread Glen Barnett
W. D. Allen Sr. [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote in message nH9u6.6370$[EMAIL PROTECTED]">news:nH9u6.6370$[EMAIL PROTECTED]... A common mistake made in statistical inference is to assume every data set is normally distributed. This seems to be the rule rather than the exception, even among

Re: Most Common Mistake In Statistical Inference

2001-03-22 Thread Alan McLean
The second sentence here ensures that generalisability to a population IS an issue for statistics. And a big issue, usually overlooked. For that matter, many applications of statistics do use sampling, not random assignment (market surveys, for example) and in these applications Dennis'

Re: Most Common Mistake In Statistical Inference

2001-03-22 Thread Elliot Cramer
given random assignment the generalizability of results to a population is not an issue for statistics. It's a question of what a plausible population is, given the procedure for obtaining subjects On Thu, 22 Mar 2001, dennis roberts wrote: using and interpreting inference procedures under

Re: Most Common Mistake In Statistical Inference

2001-03-22 Thread dennis roberts
here is my entry for the most common mistake made in statistical inference ... using and interpreting inference procedures under the assumption of SRS simple random samples ... when they just can't be this permeates across almost every technique ... and invades almost every study ever

Re: Most Common Mistake In Statistical Inference

2001-03-21 Thread Elliot Cramer
W. D. Allen Sr. [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: : Either the Chi Square or S-K test, as appropriate, should be conducted to : determine normality before interpreting population percentages using : standard deviations. I don't understand why one would want to use the normal distribution for