Re: teaching statistical methods by rules?

1999-12-20 Thread Don Taylor
With all this discussion about methods and rules I thought that this question might be appropriate: Has anyone tried using "Comprehending Behavioral Statistics" by Russell T. Hurlburt, Brooks Cole, 1994 (that I saw) It seems to be the usual sort of intro stat text, but with a twist. He makes a

Re: teaching statistical methods by rules?

1999-12-20 Thread Joe Ward
Yep!! As you say: "Why are people so obsessed with T and Z? " Perhaps it would be even better (easier?) to focus on F since F(df1,df2) = t^2(df2) (Reminder: when using a t-table, the p-values usually involve ONE-TAIL and when using the F-table, the p-values involve TWO-TAILS ) Example: The

Re: teaching statistical methods by rules?

1999-12-20 Thread Alan McLean
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: In article [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED] says... snip On the other hand, a body of knowledge can be thought of as a set of 'rules'. The important thing is that this set is constructed by the individual, so our aim should not be to teach statistics as

Re: GLIM mistake?

1999-12-20 Thread Patrick Smith
Miguel Verdu wrote: Posted also to comp.soft-sys.stat.spss where the same question appeared (and nobody answered). Hello. This is an output of GLM from SPSS 9.0 where the dependent variable FLOR (log transformed) was analysed by crossing 2 levels of the FIXED factor SEX with 2

Re: teaching statistical methods by rules?

1999-12-20 Thread Robert Dawson
Tjen-Sien Lim asks: Why are people so obsessed with T and Z? When the degrees of freedom exceeds say 30, the difference between T and Z is practically negligible. You can use T or Z in such a case. However, the P-value from Z is easier to compute. With appropriate tables or software, the

Re: Factor analysis

1999-12-20 Thread Chuck Cleland
Haider Al-Katem wrote: I have conducted a factor analysis on some questionnaire items. The dependent variables that I am measuring for example ('Intention To Buy', 'Attitude towards a product' and 'Trust in buying the product from a merchant' ) seem to load significantly high on two factors

Re: Prediction Model Question

1999-12-20 Thread Burke Johnson
Thanks for your replies, I have 5 minutes to reply to some of your comments because my wife and friends are waiting for me to get home so we can go to New Orleans. 1. I agree with Joe that the term "dummy" in dummy coding is a rather dumb term to use for indicator variables. The terms is

Re: teaching statistical methods by rules?

1999-12-20 Thread Jerry Dallal
Herman Rubin wrote: Robert Frick [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Jerry Dallal wrote: Robert Frick wrote: I know it is hard to make statistics fun, but FOLLOWING RULES IS NEVER FUN. Not in math, not in games, nowhere. In math and in games, following rules isn't just fun,

Re: Standards for Skewness

1999-12-20 Thread David A. Heiser
Skewness is only well defined for univariate distributions. The Johnson SU distribution approximation for the skewness distribution converts a Pearson skewness measure to a normal distribution Z value. As with all large data sets, a small skewness will show up as indicationg that the

Re: teaching statistical methods by rules?

1999-12-20 Thread Donald F. Burrill
On 20 Dec 1999, Don Taylor wrote in part: Has anyone tried using "Comprehending Behavioral Statistics" by Russell T. Hurlburt, Brooks Cole, 1994 (that I saw) It seems to be the usual sort of intro stat text, but with a twist. He makes a large point of showing students how to "eyeball" a

adjusting marks

1999-12-20 Thread Generic
My wife wants to adjust marks for a course she is marking. Does someone have a formula or something for using a bell curve to move them up or down? I have done this sort of thing about 15 years ago, but I can't remember any of it! --

Re: adjusting marks

1999-12-20 Thread Donald F. Burrill
Dear Why, Ted: Sign your query, and provide a usable return address, and someone might consider an answer. It might even be a useful one. But anonymous questions don't deserve a response. On Tue, 21 Dec 1999, Generic [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: My wife wants to adjust marks for a course she