Re: ANOVA = Regression

2001-12-11 Thread Dennis Roberts
of course, the typical software program, when doing regression analysis ... prints out a summary ANOVA table ... so, there is one place to start ... At 10:52 AM 12/11/01 -0500, Wuensch, Karl L wrote: For a demonstration of the equivalence of regression and traditional ANOVA, just point your

Re: ANOVA = Regression

2001-12-11 Thread Stan Brown
Jerry Dallal [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote in sci.stat.edu: It's lunch hour. I'm browsing. Shall I click on a link to a file type that has the potential to carry viruses? OT1H, Karl is a regular poster. OTOH, why run the risk? I guess I'll download and look at it in WordView. The file type was

Re: ANOVA = Regression

2001-12-11 Thread Jerry Dallal
It's lunch hour. I'm browsing. Shall I click on a link to a file type that has the potential to carry viruses? OT1H, Karl is a regular poster. OTOH, why run the risk? I guess I'll download and look at it in WordView. Wuensch, Karl L wrote: For a demonstration of the equivalence of

Re: ANOVA = Regression

2001-12-11 Thread Jerry Dallal
Stan Brown wrote: The file type was RTF. Unless I'm _VERY_ much mistaken, RTF cannot carry macros of any sort, let alone viruses. Oops, there is one loophole: Yes, a loophole. In fact, one can embed a destructive program in a pure ASCII file that can affect some machines. (Hint: it is

Re: ANOVA by items

2001-10-18 Thread jim clark
Hi On Thu, 18 Oct 2001, Wouter Duyck wrote: Suppose i have a factorial design with two between-subject factors (one factor A of 3 levels and one factor B of 2 levels) en two within-subject factors (one factor C of 2 levels and one factor D of 5 levels). Of course, to perform an ANOVA on this

Re: ANOVA problem

2001-09-15 Thread Glen
Rich Ulrich [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote in message news:[EMAIL PROTECTED]... On Fri, 14 Sep 2001 16:44:11 + (UTC), Asst Professor [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I have data from a 24 item (1-4 likert scale) survey for 5 groups with varying Ns (9,16,23,34,43). According to the Levene

Re: ANOVA problem

2001-09-14 Thread Rich Ulrich
On Fri, 14 Sep 2001 16:44:11 + (UTC), Asst Professor [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I have data from a 24 item (1-4 likert scale) survey for 5 groups with varying Ns (9,16,23,34,43). According to the Levene homogeniety of variance test, I also have varying means for some questions and not

Re: ANOVA and regression

2001-05-30 Thread jim clark
Hi On 29 May 2001, Alex Yu wrote: Does anyone know any book/paper/website about teaching the relationship between ANOVA and regression? I have Data Analysis for Research Designs by Keppel. I also seached www.jstor.org but could not find anything. I am interested in seeing what approaches

Re: Hypothesis testing, was: Re: ANOVA anomaly?

2001-05-21 Thread Herman Rubin
In article 9e9tkq$n1$[EMAIL PROTECTED], Robert Dodier [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I wrote: Mr. Eckmann is clearly thinking about the probability that mean1 equals mean2, or the probability that mean1, ..., mean4 are all equal. There is no reason to dissuade him from this; that the machinery of

Re: ANOVA : Repeated Measures?

2001-02-14 Thread Sylvain Clément
Thank you very much for your answer to my problem. Your explanation are very clear precise. I wish I could have meet a professor in stats as clear as you are during my high school education. Sylvain Clement At 14:19 09/02/2001 -0500, Donald Burrill wrote: If for each Subject

Re: ANOVA : Repeated Measures?

2001-02-09 Thread Paul R Swank
Whether or not to use random effects should depend on whether you wish to generalize the results to some populations that the sample is (hopefully) representative of. Usually we wish to generalize to some population of subjects. Typically (but not neccesarily) we are not interested in generalizing

Re: ANOVA : Repeated Measures?

2001-02-09 Thread Donald Burrill
If for each Subject you have 4 Measures in each of the 3 Conditions, then both Conditions and Measures are repeated-measures factors: you design may be symbolized as S x C x M -- that is, Subjects (5 levels) are crossed with both Conditions and Measures. This design is equivalent to

Re: ANOVA with dichotomous dependent variable

2000-11-06 Thread Joseph McDonnell
I may be wrong, but I thought that Gerhard was asking something like "If I perform a linear regression but with a dichotomous dependent variable, do I get 'garbage' results?" Joseph Gene Gallagher wrote: In article [EMAIL PROTECTED], Gerhard Luecke [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Can anyone

Re: ANOVA with dichotomous dependent variable

2000-11-06 Thread Herman Rubin
In article [EMAIL PROTECTED], Joseph McDonnell [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I may be wrong, but I thought that Gerhard was asking something like "If I perform a linear regression but with a dichotomous dependent variable, do I get 'garbage' results?" The results must be at least partly garbage. We

Re: ANOVA with dichotomous dependent variable

2000-11-06 Thread Rich Ulrich
On Mon, 06 Nov 2000 18:36:16 +0100, Joseph McDonnell [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Gentlemen, I agree with both of you. Several correspondents had already pointed out that a logistic regression approach would be more appropriate in this situation. However, I was trying to steer the discussion

Re: ANOVA with dichotomous dependent variable

2000-11-03 Thread Gene Gallagher
In article [EMAIL PROTECTED], Gerhard Luecke [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Can anyone name some references where the problem of using a DICHOTOMOUS variable as a DEPENDENT variable in an ANOVA is discussed? Many thanks in advance, Gerhard Luecke Check out Ramsey Schaefer's "The Statistical

Re: ANOVA with dichotomous dependent variable

2000-11-02 Thread Paul Thompson
Gerhard Luecke wrote: Can anyone name some references where the problem of using a DICHOTOMOUS variable as a DEPENDENT variable in an ANOVA is discussed? Many thanks in advance, Gerhard Luecke Such analyses may be done using either logistic regression methods or generalized estimating

Re: ANOVA with dichotomous dependent variable

2000-11-02 Thread Glen Barnett
Gerhard Luecke wrote: Can anyone name some references where the problem of using a DICHOTOMOUS variable as a DEPENDENT variable in an ANOVA is discussed? Many thanks in advance, Gerhard Luecke I'd first try logistic regression. If all your variables are categorical, you can look at some

Re: ANOVA question on transformed variable

2000-09-26 Thread Rich Ulrich
On 24 Sep 2000 23:30:57 -0700, [EMAIL PROTECTED] (Beng Hai Chea) wrote: I have a very basic ANOVA question regarding transformed variable. Example: I have 6 different types of habitats and I have obtained 25 readings from each of the different type of habitats. After doing the ANOVA

Re: ANOVA question on transformed variable

2000-09-26 Thread Beng Hai Chea
I have a very basic ANOVA question regarding transformed variable. Example: I have 6 different types of habitats and I have obtained 25 readings from each of the different type of habitats. After doing the ANOVA procedure, I discovered that non-constant error variance is present.

Re: ANOVA, Robustness, and Power

2000-06-23 Thread Donald Burrill
On Thu, 22 Jun 2000, Alex Yu wrote (slightly edited): ANOVA is said to be robust against assumption violations when the sample size is large. However, when the sample size is huge, it tends to overpower the test and thus the null may be falsely rejected. Which is a lesser evil? Your

Re: ANOVA: planned comparisons

2000-05-17 Thread Donald F. Burrill
It rather sounds as though data are already in hand, rather than yet to be collected. That being the case, as I shall assume, your 2nd model has half the data that your 1st model has, and it is not clear whether this reflects the discarding of half the available data, or the averaging

Re: ANOVA causal direction

2000-02-24 Thread William Chambers
Bill said earlier: Yes, we do this so that we will have examples of all combinations of x1 and x2,as we would do when using a factorial anova design. But such uniform sampling does not make the variables into causes, Adding x1 to x2 causes y, Gus responded: Here you are using a very

Re: ANOVA causal direction

2000-02-23 Thread Gus Gassmann
William Chambers wrote: Gus, You are making a defense of studying distributions as they are thrown at us by nature/circumstances, This seem the way to go to social scientists because we tend to believe that our causes are embedded in all sorts of complex interactions and can not be

Re: ANOVA causal direction

2000-02-23 Thread William Chambers
Gus said: Here is how I interpret what you've said to date: 1. If you take two uniformly distributed random variables x1 and x2 and form the sum y = x1 + x2, then y has a distribution that is not uniform. 2. If you have two variables x and y and want to determine whether x depends on y or

Re: ANOVA causal direction

2000-02-23 Thread William Chambers
Guss said: No. You said yourself that you are _selecting_ the x1 and x2 to be uniform. Yes, we do this so that we will have examples of all combinations of x1 and x2,as we would do when using a factorial anova design. But such uniform sampling does not make the variables into causes, Adding

Re: ANOVA causal direction

2000-02-22 Thread William Chambers
Gus, You are making a defense of studying distributions as they are thrown at us by nature/circumstances, This seem the way to go to social scientists because we tend to believe that our causes are embedded in all sorts of complex interactions and can not be isolated from their context, If we

Re: ANOVA causal direction

2000-02-11 Thread Bruce Weaver
On 10 Feb 2000, Richard M. Barton wrote: --- Alex Yu wrote: A statistical procedure alone cannot determine casual relationships. --- Correct. A lot depends on eye contact. rb And also, at least 2 statistical procedures are required...

Re: ANOVA causal direction

2000-02-10 Thread dennis roberts
At 12:40 PM 2/10/00 +, sofyan2000 wrote: Is there a statistical test in ANOVA / MANOVA that can show the causal direction between 2 variables (Independent and Dependent). i don't think so ... this is determined (if it can be at all) by the DESIGN of the investigation ... and what you did

Re: ANOVA causal direction

2000-02-10 Thread Alex Yu
A statistical procedure alone cannot determine casual relationships. Rather it involves the design and measurement issues. The following is extracted from my handout: One of the objectives of conducting experiments is to make causal inferences. At least three criteria need to be fulfilled to

Re: ANOVA causal direction

2000-02-10 Thread Richard M. Barton
--- Alex Yu wrote: A statistical procedure alone cannot determine casual relationships. --- Correct. A lot depends on eye contact. rb === This list is open to everyone. Occasionally, people lacking respect for

Re: ANOVA causal direction

2000-02-10 Thread Travis Gee
sofyan2000 wrote: Is there a statistical test in ANOVA / MANOVA that can show the causal direction between 2 variables (Independent and Dependent). In short, no. In more detail, causal inference is dependent on the design you used, not the statistical technique applied to the data. If you

Re: ANOVA data

2000-02-09 Thread Zina Taran
hmmm. what is variance-between groups when all of them are standardized? am I missing something? - Original Message - From: haytham siala [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, February 09, 2000 5:12 PM Subject: ANOVA data Can I perform an ANOVA on standardized

Re: ANOVA data

2000-02-09 Thread David A. Heiser
- Original Message - From: haytham siala [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, February 09, 2000 2:12 PM Subject: ANOVA data Can I perform an ANOVA on standardized variables? --- If you

Re: ANOVA/ MANOVA

2000-02-08 Thread Thom Baguley
sofyan2000 wrote: I have conducted a repeated measure mixed two-factor ANOVA on one sample consisting of 2 groups (conservatives and liberals). The dependent variables where ATTA (attitude towards policy A) and ATTB (attitude towardfs B). I have a few questions: 1. What statistical ANOVA

Re: ANOVA/ MANOVA

2000-02-08 Thread Rich Ulrich
On Mon, 7 Feb 2000 18:42:03 -, "sofyan2000" [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: 3. Which part of the SPSS results (which heading?) afer running an MANOVA shows the interaction between the between groups IV (political category conservative vs. liberals) and the within-groups DV (ATTA ATTB).

Re: ANOVA/ MANOVA

2000-02-07 Thread Elliot Cramer
In sci.stat.consult sofyan2000 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: : I have conducted a repeated measure mixed two-factor ANOVA on one sample you shouldn't have : 1. What statistical ANOVA test can reveal an outlier in my data? none : 2. If my test failed the 'homogeneity of variance/ covariance' test,

Re: ANOVA

2000-02-06 Thread Rich Ulrich
On Sat, 5 Feb 2000 16:46:38 -, "haytham siala" [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Is the homogoneity of variance-covariance prerequisite to ANOVA a requirement? No, it is a warning that your model might be inappropriate, in any of several ways. A single EXTREME outlier could make any average

Re: ANOVA with proportions

1999-12-15 Thread Rich Ulrich
On 14 Dec 1999 08:40:18 -0800, [EMAIL PROTECTED] (William B. Ware) wrote: As I recall, there was an article by Lunney et al that appeared in the Journal of Educational Measurement that examined the use of ANOVA with "1" and "0" as the DV. I believe that they concluded that distortion was

Re: ANOVA with proportions

1999-12-15 Thread Rich Ulrich
On 14 Dec 1999 16:38:00 -0800, [EMAIL PROTECTED] (Rich Strauss) wrote: snip I'll just add the usual caveat that hasn't yet been mentioned in these responses about proportions: the transformations, use of the binomial, and comment about proportions just being means all assume that the data

Re: ANOVA with proportions

1999-12-14 Thread Donald F. Burrill
On Tue, 14 Dec 1999, Wouter Duyck wrote: I have a question. I have n subjects. For each subject, I have a proportion. I want to test if there are some differences in that proportion, depending on some independent variables (e.g. sex) on which the subjects differ. Can I use those

Re: ANOVA with proportions

1999-12-14 Thread Dale Berger
___ On Tue, 14 Dec 1999, Robert Dawson wrote: - Original Message - From: Donald F. Burrill [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Wouter Duyck [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cc: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Tuesday, December 14, 1999 9:03 AM Subject: Re: ANOVA with proportions On Tue, 14 Dec 1999, Wouter D

Re: ANOVA with proportions

1999-12-14 Thread sean_flanigan
In article [EMAIL PROTECTED], Wouter Duyck [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi to all... i have a question. I have n subjects. for each subject, i have a proportion. i wanna test if there are some differences in that proportion, depending on some independent variables (e.g. sexe) on wich the