Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :)

2006-04-11 Thread Vern Ceder
On Tue, 2006-04-11 at 10:00 +0100, Peter Bowyer wrote: In the meantime, if anyone wants to read and comment on a 35 page document on the rationale behind teaching introductory programming using Python, I have one :) Yes, please... Vern -- This time for sure! -Bullwinkle J. Moose

Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :)

2006-04-11 Thread kirby urner
Indeed. Could we set up a separate Kirby and Arthur list, so those who enjoy watching their Itchy and Scratchy show antics could do so somewhere else? Apologies. I have hardly any more budget for replies to Arthur on any but narrow topics related to his curriculum writing around PyGeo (have

Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :)

2006-04-11 Thread Peter Bowyer
At 13:50 11/04/2006, kirby urner wrote: I have hardly any more budget for replies to Arthur on any but narrow topics related to his curriculum writing around PyGeo (have you seen it?). No, and at present I'm not bothered :) Maths education isn't my thing. Is it better than Zelle's? Not at all.

Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :)

2006-04-11 Thread Gregor Lingl
Peter Bowyer schrieb: At 01:39 11/04/2006, Andre Roberge wrote: ... In the meantime, if anyone wants to read and comment on a 35 page document on the rationale behind teaching introductory programming using Python, I have one :) Me too, please ... Gregor Kind regards, Peter --

Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :)

2006-04-11 Thread kirby urner
On 4/11/06, Peter Bowyer [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: No, and at present I'm not bothered :) Maths education isn't my thing. OK, I see that. Catching up on your blog. Kirby ___ Edu-sig mailing list Edu-sig@python.org

Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :)

2006-04-11 Thread Brad Miller
On Apr 11, 2006, at 7:50 AM, kirby urner wrote: In the meantime, if anyone wants to read and comment on a 35 page document on the rationale behind teaching introductory programming using Python, I have one :) Please count me in. Is it better than Zelle's? I think the pro Python case has

Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :)

2006-04-11 Thread Grégoire Dooms
Message: 1 Date: Mon, 10 Apr 2006 17:32:37 -0700 From: Scott David Daniels [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :) The attention and discussion that used to go on on this list about Python and education. When you post at a ration approaching, and at times

Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :)

2006-04-11 Thread Brad Miller
On Apr 11, 2006, at 1:19 PM, Scott David Daniels wrote:One idea I had some time ago is using Python for visualizations.In particular, I once built an iterator-based visualization of DBquery processing (based on old collaborative work with my erstwhileoffice-mate Bennet Vance) that makes it

Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :)

2006-04-10 Thread kirby urner
For example, I don't buy that it's an either/or situation. You seem to think a Klein-reading Euclid-drawing subgenius, properly suspicious of Bucky (maybe armed with a few Bucky jokes) can't suddenly jump up and run over to an Alice workstation, there to play with cute skiing bunnies and other

Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :)

2006-04-10 Thread Arthur
kirby urner wrote: For example, I don't buy that it's an either/or situation. You seem to think a Klein-reading Euclid-drawing subgenius, properly suspicious of Bucky (maybe armed with a few Bucky jokes) can't suddenly jump up and run over to an Alice workstation, there to play with cute skiing

Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :)

2006-04-10 Thread kirby urner
CS and hard science and Alice being mentioned as an alternative. Willamette University is offering an art major centered around computers. For a lot of kids, the big question is: how do I get a job making Shrek type movies or with Industrial Light and Magic. They hear (correctly) that it

Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :)

2006-04-10 Thread ajsiegel
- Original Message - From: kirby urner [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Monday, April 10, 2006 11:56 am Subject: Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :) CS and hard science and Alice being mentioned as an alternative. Willamette University is offering an art major centered around computers

Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :)

2006-04-10 Thread kirby urner
So you argree that Alice is overreaching and out-of-line with a statement like Alice is not big on my radar. It's not even a Python project. When it comes to protecting the integrity of CS from watering down, I look to people stronger than you to fight the dumbing down influences. I think

Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :)

2006-04-10 Thread ajsiegel
- Original Message - From: kirby urner [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Monday, April 10, 2006 3:07 pm Subject: Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :) So you argree that Alice is overreaching and out-of-line with a statement like Alice is not big on my radar. Glad to hear it. It's

Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :)

2006-04-10 Thread ajsiegel
- Original Message - From: kirby urner [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Monday, April 10, 2006 4:44 pm Subject: Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :) Are comments by me, here going to influence outcomes. Probably not. Worth a shot? What's to lose. Let some people go with Alice

Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :)

2006-04-10 Thread kirby urner
I look to to me less ungenerous than you look to me. Must be just the point of view. Art Anyway, PyGeo is online, free, downloadable, and kids grooving on it (might be several) will have the power themselves to figure the redistro angle, via apt-get or whatever. It's what they know. You,

Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :)

2006-04-10 Thread Scott David Daniels
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: kirby urner [EMAIL PROTECTED] Alice is not big on my radar. Glad to hear it. It's not even a Python project. It is brought up here and now specifically in the context of it having been noted at U of Mich as competition to and with a Python project,

[Edu-sig] The end is near :)

2006-04-09 Thread Arthur
* Carnegie Mellon Collaborates with EA to Revolutionize And Reinvigorate Computer Science Education in the US** *http://www.alice.org/index2.html ___ Edu-sig mailing list Edu-sig@python.org http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/edu-sig

Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :)

2006-04-09 Thread kirby urner
For the record - rather its on the record, *here* - is the fact that I have been following Alice with a good degree of horror for some 5 years. For the record, I'm somewhat interested in what you're *for* but what you're against I don't pay much attention to. You've goofed up too much. What

Re: [Edu-sig] The end is near :)

2006-04-09 Thread Arthur
-Original Message- From: kirby urner [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Arthur You've goofed up too much. What more need I say? You needn't say even that. But you have. ;) Art ___ Edu-sig mailing list Edu-sig@python.org