Re: [Elecraft] FAR OT: Grounding and lightning

2018-04-26 Thread Jim Brown
On 4/25/2018 10:15 PM, David Gilbert wrote: It does not advance the technical competency level of our hobby to make broad generalizations based upon narrow and poorly defined anecdotal instances. Strongly agree. 73, Jim K9YC __

Re: [Elecraft] FAR OT: Grounding and lightning

2018-04-25 Thread David Gilbert
If that was actually the case, I would surmise that the "ground rods" were not connected to a proper rebar cage (i.e., Ufer ground) that would normally be able to able to distribute the lightning current over a sufficiently large surface.  Simply putting a couple of ground rods inside a

[Elecraft] FAR OT: Grounding and lightning

2018-04-25 Thread john
It appears that you are describing a Ufer ground. It should not explode, especially if these internal ground rods were properly bonded to the rebar. John KK9A Ken G Kopp K0PP wrote: I should have been more specific in suggesting that grounds that might end up carrying a lightening charge not

[Elecraft] FAR OT: Grounding and lightning

2018-04-25 Thread Ken G Kopp
I should have been more specific in suggesting that grounds that might end up carrying a lightening charge not be run through concrete. The following is from personal "real world" experience. I know of two specific cases where tower bases were blown apart by lightning hits to the towers because