Re: [Elecraft] The weekness of a d'arsonval watt meter

2009-07-21 Thread dw
Thanks Don! I aggree with you. I used to calibrate RF-electro-surgery devices in a former life :) Thanks for the tip on the non-reactive power resistor. I think I will look to get one. Good stuff!. Duane On Mon, 20 Jul 2009 21:07 -0400, Don Wilhelm w3...@embarqmail.com wrote: Duane, While

Re: [Elecraft] The weekness of a d'arsonval watt meter

2009-07-21 Thread Fred Jensen
dw wrote: Some day a smart ham is going to manufacture and sell a mico-chip based watt-meter which the user can calibrate himself using a bird meter Someone already has and does. It's called a W1 and it is sold by Elecraft. I have one, mine is in a nifty polycarbonate case from W8FGU, and

Re: [Elecraft] The weekness of a d'arsonval watt meter

2009-07-21 Thread Eric Swartz - WA6HHQ, Elecraft
And same for the upcoming W2 :-) http://www.elecraft.com/manual/W2%20Data%20Sheet%20rev%204sm.pdf 73, Eric WA6HHQ Fred Jensen wrote: dw wrote: Some day a smart ham is going to manufacture and sell a mico-chip based watt-meter which the user can calibrate himself using a bird meter

[Elecraft] The weekness of a d'arsonval watt meter

2009-07-20 Thread dw
If I am correct, most manufactures claim a 10% tolerance on most d'arsonval type watt meters. I believe there are also some caveats. That 10% is at a specified level of applied wattage, and of course applied into a 50 ohm load. This means that at 100 watts applied power, the meter can read +/- 10

Re: [Elecraft] The weekness of a d'arsonval watt meter

2009-07-20 Thread Don Wilhelm
Duane, While you are correct on the meter movement specs, take a hard look at the wattmeters available to hams. The LP-100 wattmeter does almost what you are referring to. It is quite accurate when calibrated. I have a general mistrust on analog reading wattmeters. Many wattmeters on the