[Election-Methods] Partisan Politics

2008-03-23 Thread Fred Gohlke
Good Afternoon, David re: How would you do better? Well, for starters, I'd ponder ways to empower the electorate by harnessing our nature and de-emphasizing partisanship. I'm sure there are many ways that can be done. You'll find an outline of one possibility at [Election-Methods]

[Election-Methods] Partisan Politics

2008-03-23 Thread Fred Gohlke
Good Afternoon, Juho Is it possible you have not read my February 4th post, Selecting Leaders From the People? It describes an election method I call Active Democracy. If not, that may explain some of the confusion in our discussion. Throughout our exchange, I've been under the impression

[Election-Methods] A better IRV (was Re: Range Voting won't eliminate spoilers)

2008-03-23 Thread Chris Benham
Steve Eppley wrote: IRV might cause polarization even worse than what we already have, since the effective plurality rule campaign strategy of shifting toward the centrist swing voters after being nominated--which reduces polarization somewhat--would risk, under IRV, the late entry of an

Re: [Election-Methods] Partisan Politics

2008-03-23 Thread Abd ul-Rahman Lomax
At 08:03 PM 3/18/2008, Fred Gohlke wrote: Good Evening, Dave re: In New York, at least, the two major parties each do such as appoint half the members of the Boards of Elections. and also in regard to the related comments about party leadership, party activities, party business, state party, and

Re: [Election-Methods] Partisan Politics

2008-03-23 Thread Juho Laatu
--- Fred Gohlke [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I hope you'll read (or re-read) the February 4th post. I already earlier tried to summarize my viewpoint when I said As you can see my concerns and possible improvements that I'd like to study are mainly in the areas of privacy of the votes and in

[Election-Methods] How to get from here to there, was Re: Partisan Politics

2008-03-23 Thread Abd ul-Rahman Lomax
At 05:09 PM 3/23/2008, Juho Laatu wrote: The method now presents one very clean viewpoint. The method introduces some clear benefits but also some problems. I'd maybe try to find a method that would keep most of the benefits and eliminate most of the problems. (There could be many paths forward.)

Re: [Election-Methods] YN model - simple voting model in which range optimal, others not

2008-03-23 Thread Dan Bishop
Dave Ketchum wrote: On Sat, 22 Mar 2008 19:35:13 -0400 Warren Smith wrote: The YN model - a simple voting model in which range voting behaves optimally while many competing voting systems (including Condorcet) can behave pessimally: http://rangevoting.org/PuzzAggreg.html When I