Re: [EM] MJ SFR (preliminary). Score vs Approval, based on considerations discussed.

2012-09-11 Thread Michael Ossipoff
Ted: You said: Majority Judgment (MJ) and Continuous Majority Judgment (CMJ) are both Median Ratings methods. No sh*t ! :-)...But wait, isn't that explicit in their definition? As is ER-Bucklin(whole). You're probably most familiar with the latter, so let me start there. I will put

Re: [EM] MJ SFR (preliminary). Score vs Approval, based on considerations discussed.

2012-09-11 Thread Ted Stern
On 11 Sep 2012 13:18:23 -0700, Michael Ossipoff wrote: Ted: You said: Majority Judgment (MJ) and Continuous Majority Judgment (CMJ) are both Median Ratings methods. No sh*t ! :-)...But wait, isn't that explicit in their definition? As is ER-Bucklin(whole). You're probably most

Re: [EM] MJ SFR (preliminary). Score vs Approval, based on considerations discussed.

2012-09-11 Thread Michael Ossipoff
Ok. I've heard the claim that MJ is ER-Bucklin. Maybe it's true. Here is where you go off track: I don't think this has ever been claimed, and certainly not by myself. Fine. They aren't equivalent. Issue resolved, and subject closed. But what would their equivalence (if valid) There is