[EM] Juho: Sincere ranking, contd.

2012-11-17 Thread Michael Ossipoff
Juho: On 15.11.2012, at 18.00, Michael Ossipoff wrote: If I ranked all of the candidates sincerely, the Democrat and the Republican would be at the bottom of that ranking. Even if they're winnable. So you can't say that not ranking unwinnable candidates allows you to vote a short ranking.

[EM] Symmetrical IC-RP(losing-votes) or Symmetrical IC-Beatpath(losing-votes)?

2012-11-17 Thread Michael Ossipoff
What if equal ranking at top and bottom were treated as in Symmetrical ICT, but the completion was by Beatpath or Ranked-Pairs, instead of by top-count? If it was Beatpath(losing-votes), or Ranked-Pairs(losing-votes), would that confer CD compliance, avoiding the Approval bad-example? It seems to