Re: [EM] Critique of FairVote's approval voting report

2011-10-11 Thread Kristofer Munsterhjelm
robert bristow-johnson wrote: dunno if i can do much critiquing of that particular doc. what i like is in FairVote's page: http://www.fairvote.org/single-winner-voting-method-comparison-chart where they claim that IRV will do a better job getting the Condorcet winner than does Condorcet

[EM] Critique of FairVote's approval voting report

2011-10-10 Thread Jameson Quinn
I would like to make a detailed critique of the FairVote report they've put up at approvalvoting.blogspot.com and rangevoting.com. I believe that every single one of the conclusions of that report is dangerously wrong. I've created a google

Re: [EM] Critique of FairVote's approval voting report

2011-10-10 Thread robert bristow-johnson
dunno if i can do much critiquing of that particular doc. what i like is in FairVote's page: http://www.fairvote.org/single-winner-voting-method-comparison-chart where they claim that IRV will do a better job getting the Condorcet winner than does Condorcet (sometimes the Condorcet method