Re: [Election-Methods] Fwd: [Election Methhods] MCA's IIB problem fixed

2008-01-28 Thread Kevin Venzke
Chris, --- Chris Benham [EMAIL PROTECTED] a écrit : Kevin, In your latest post you alluded to MCA's failure of Independence from Irrelevant Ballots (IIB): A nice thing about the majority requirement is that if it's assumed that you are going to vote, there's no way that your vote can

Re: [Election-Methods] Fwd: [Election Methhods] MCA's IIB problem fixed

2008-01-28 Thread Chris Benham
Kevin, Kevin Venzke wrote: I also don't find the FBC-satisfying version of MCA to be a significant improvement over Approval. I like it better than 3-slot CR. I agree that in scenarios where it is known to be very likely no majority first-round winner then it is just Approval with extra