[Election-Methods] How is the Nanson and/or Baldwin non-monotonic?

2007-09-20 Thread John Wong
How is the Nanson and/or Baldwin non-monotonic? I've been trying to develop an example where they are non-monotonic, but I'm having trouble. _ Share your special parenting moments! http://www.reallivemoms.com?ocid=TXT_TAGHMloc=us

Re: [Election-Methods] How is the Nanson and/or Baldwin non-monotonic?

2007-09-20 Thread John Wong
It doesn't seem that Nanson or Baldwin has quite the same degree of problem with monotonicity as IRV does. Is Baldwin/Nanson less non-monotonic? From: Chris Benham [EMAIL PROTECTED] Reply-To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: John Wong [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [Election-Methods] How is the Nanson

Re: [Election-Methods] How is the Nanson and/or Baldwin non-monotonic?

2007-09-20 Thread Chris Benham
John Wong wrote: How is the Nanson and/or Baldwin non-monotonic? I've been trying to develop an example where they are non-monotonic, but I'm having trouble. I think this is an example of Borda Elimination (Baldwin?) failing mono-raise. 31: AB 32: BC 03: AC 31: CA 03: CB Borda scores: