Re: [Election-Methods] RE : Re: Fwd: FYI - FairVote MN Responds toLawsuit Against IRV

2007-12-26 Thread James Gilmour
-- Kathy Dopp a écrit : I do find that ballots (2nd choices) of some, but not all voters is considered with IRV, and hence my opinion is that it does not treat all voters' ballots equally and should be considered illegal under any law that requires the ballots of all voters to be

Re: [Election-Methods] RE : Re: Fwd: FYI - FairVote MN Responds toLawsuit Against IRV

2007-12-26 Thread Dave Ketchum
I have to charge: Kathy with complaining about IRV, with incorrect reasoning. Kevin with incomplete arguments as to limited ranking. James with defending IRV, again with incomplete reasoning. On Wed, 26 Dec 2007 13:00:09 - James Gilmour wrote: -- Kathy Dopp a écrit : I