On Mar 15, 2008, at 19:55 , Michael Rouse wrote:
I have one concern - the behaviour of the counting method with
clones. Let's multiply one of the candidates (A => A1 and A2). Then
we would have: 1: A1=10 A2=10 B=2 C=1 D=0 1: A1=10 A2=10 C=7 B=6 D=0
1: B=10 C=6 A1=5 A2=5 D=0 3: C=10 D=5 A1=1 A2=1
Let me know if this is formatted incorrectly -- it word wraps just fine
in Thunderbird, but I don't know if other email programs display it
correctly.
Sorry it's taken so long to reply -- it's been a hectic week.
I also apologize for the length of the message, which probably causes
eyes to gla
The explanation was clear enough for me.
I have one concern - the behaviour of the counting method with
clones. Let's multiply one of the candidates (A => A1 and A2). Then
we would have:
1: A1=10 A2=10 B=2 C=1 D=0
1: A1=10 A2=10 C=7 B=6 D=0
1: B=10 C=6 A1=5 A2=5 D=0
3: C=10 D=5 A1=1 A2=1 B=0
3
Snipping the message:**On Mar 3, 2008, at 1:45 , <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:> [EMAIL PROTECTED]:>> >>Can you also clarify a bit how step 3 is counted when some candidate X is beaten by two other candidates (Y and Z).> >>I find the proposed method interesting s
On Mar 3, 2008, at 1:45 , <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
wrote:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]:
>>Can you also clarify a bit how step 3 is counted when some
candidate X is beaten by two other candidates (Y and Z).
>>I find the proposed method interesting since it seems to aim at
electing go
At 03:20 PM 3/2/2008, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
>I'm curious about voting methods that take ranked ballot methods and
>adapt them to range ballots. For example, with Baldwin's method, you
>take drop the candidate with the lowest Borda score, recalculate,
>and so on. A range variant might drop th
[EMAIL PROTECTED]:>>Check also James Green-Armytage's cardinal-weighted pairwise comparison method if you haven't don that yet. => http://fc.antioch.edu/~james_green-armytage/cwp13.htmThanks, I'll do that!>>Can you also clarify a bit how step 3 is counted when some candidate X is beaten by two othe
Check also James Green-Armytage's cardinal-weighted pairwise
comparison method if you haven't don that yet. => http://
fc.antioch.edu/~james_green-armytage/cwp13.htm
Can you also clarify a bit how step 3 is counted when some candidate
X is beaten by two other candidates (Y and Z).
I find t
Just an addendum from previous post (Minimum Distance Condorcet Completion). I'm curious about voting methods that take ranked ballot methods and adapt them to range ballots. For example, with Baldwin's method, you take drop the candidate with the lowest Borda score, recalculate, and so on. A range
