Re: [EM] British Colombia considering change to STV

2009-05-02 Thread Juho Laatu
--- On Thu, 30/4/09, Raph Frank raph...@gmail.com wrote: In Ireland, the constitution requires at least 3 per constituency and over time the average number of seats per constituency is being reduced. It is currently illegal (by statutory law) for constituencies to have more than 5 seats.

Re: [EM] British Colombia considering change to STV

2009-05-02 Thread James Gilmour
Juho Laatu Sent: Saturday, May 02, 2009 11:33 PM In Ireland, the constitution requires at least 3 per constituency and over time the average number of seats per constituency is being reduced. It is currently illegal (by statutory law) for constituencies to have more than 5 seats.

Re: [EM] British Colombia considering change to STV

2009-05-02 Thread Anthony O'Neal
It is a rather huge problem. It effects the proportionately surprisingly little though - all the major parties still win a roughly fair number of seats. Districting tends to produce much more proportional results than the seat size would suggest, as random political differences in geography

Re: [EM] British Colombia considering change to STV

2009-05-02 Thread Raph Frank
On Sat, May 2, 2009 at 11:33 PM, Juho Laatu juho4...@yahoo.co.uk wrote: It practice that seems to set the limits to max 4 and min 2 parties/groupings per constituency represented in the Dail. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Members_of_the_30th_D%C3%A1il\ The small constituency sizes do hurt the

Re: [EM] British Colombia considering change to STV

2009-05-02 Thread Raph Frank
On Sun, May 3, 2009 at 12:13 AM, Anthony O'Neal watermar...@gmail.com wrote: It is a rather huge problem.  It effects the proportionately surprisingly little though - all the major parties still win a roughly fair number of seats.  Districting tends to produce much more proportional results