Kevin Venzke has come up with an example that shows that my Strong
Minimal Defense, Top Ratings
(SMD,TR) method fails the Plurality criterion,contrary to what I've claimed.
21: AC
08: BA
23: B
11: C
Approval scores: A29, B31, C32
Maximum Approval Opposition scores: A11, B32, C31
My previous message contained a small blunder. The corrected version is below
A candidate X's maximum approval oppostion score is the approval score of
the most approved
candidate only on ballots on which X is not approved.
In the example election I mistakenly gave A's MAO score as 11.
The
