RE: [EM] Runoff terminology --> Seeded Condorcet

2001-03-14 Thread LAYTON Craig
Forest wrote: >I think that all candidates with less than 50% approval should be >eliminated, except perhaps when that would eliminate all of them. This might not solve the problem of handing the result to a 'bad Condorcet winner' if, as I strongly suspect, there will be many cases where no cand

RE: [EM] Runoff terminology --> Seeded Condorcet

2001-03-13 Thread Forest Simmons
On Wed, 14 Mar 2001, LAYTON Craig wrote: > Forest wrote: > > >Would "instant voteoff" be too suggestive of elimination (even though it > >naturally includes full Condorcet through the round robin playoff analogy > >mentioned above)? > > That sounds a bit Survivor. > > >By the way, I'm no spo

RE: [EM] Runoff terminology --> Seeded Condorcet

2001-03-13 Thread LAYTON Craig
Forest wrote: >Would "instant voteoff" be too suggestive of elimination (even though it >naturally includes full Condorcet through the round robin playoff analogy >mentioned above)? That sounds a bit Survivor. >By the way, I'm no sports fan, but I understand that the playoff >tournaments of the

Re: [EM] Runoff terminology --> Seeded Condorcet

2001-03-13 Thread Steve Barney
>Forest Simmons wrote: > > > "Instant Round Robin" would convey the idea of full Condorcet to sports > > fans. > > > > "Instant Tournament" or "Instant Playoffs" would include simulated single > > elimination, double elimination, and round robin concepts. Isn't the Borda Count used to rank colleg

Re: [EM] Runoff terminology --> Seeded Condorcet

2001-03-12 Thread Richard Moore
Forest Simmons wrote: > "Instant Round Robin" would convey the idea of full Condorcet to sports > fans. > > "Instant Tournament" or "Instant Playoffs" would include simulated single > elimination, double elimination, and round robin concepts. If there is a Condorcet winner then single eliminatio

[EM] Runoff terminology --> Seeded Condorcet

2001-03-12 Thread Forest Simmons
Thanks Richard, I'll incorporate all of your valuable suggestions one way or another. I guess that "Instant Runoff Voting" is intended to be a simulated version of a certain kind of actual runoff where the voters are required to go to the polls up to N-1 times when there are N candidates. It's i