Re: [O] Bug (?) in new exporter (export subtree)

2013-01-18 Thread Nicolas Goaziou 
Rick Frankel r...@rickster.com writes:

 So, it seems that as long as there is a body (or blank) line after the
 parent heading and you position the cursor on that line, it works
 (point at X):

 #+begin_src org
 * Title
   X
 ** heading 1
text
 ** heading 2
...
 #+end_src

 But if there is no blank line after the title, there is no way to
 get the expected results with the point either on the title line or
 the first asterix on heading 1:

 #+begin_src org
 * Title
 ** heading 1
text
 ** heading 2
...
 #+end_src

Indeed, you have to be within the subtree you want to export in order to
effectively export it. In your example there's no such place, so there's
no way to tell which subtree you want to be exported.

This is a reasonable behaviour in my opinion.


Regards,

-- 
Nicolas Goaziou

Re: [O] Bug (?) in new exporter (export subtree)

2013-01-17 Thread Rick Frankel 
On Wed, Jan 16, 2013 at 07:36:10PM +0100, Nicolas Goaziou wrote:
 Rick Frankel r...@rickster.com writes:
 
  In the new exporter, when the option to export only the subtree is
  specified, the first heading in the subtree is used as the title of
  the document. This seems wrong, as it becomes the title, the first
  element in the table of contents and the first (not necessarily
  the top level) section in the document.
 
 It doesn't, AFAIU. Could you explain how you do export (in particular,
 where is the point when you call the export subtree process) and what do
 you expect on a simple example ?
 
 For me:
 
 #+begin_src org
 #+TITLE: title
 #+OPTIONS: toc:t
 * Level 1
   Body 1 X
 ** Level 2
Body 2
 *** Level 3
 Body 3
 #+end_src
 
 with point at X will have Level 1 as its title, but Level 1 will
 appear neither in the table of contents nor as the first section of the
 produced document.

So, it seems that as long as there is a body (or blank) line after the
parent heading and you position the cursor on that line, it works
(point at X):

#+begin_src org
* Title
  X
** heading 1
   text
** heading 2
   ...
#+end_src

But if there is no blank line after the title, there is no way to
get the expected results with the point either on the title line or
the first asterix on heading 1:

#+begin_src org
* Title
** heading 1
   text
** heading 2
   ...
#+end_src


rick

Re: [O] Bug (?) in new exporter (export subtree)

2013-01-16 Thread Nicolas Goaziou 
Hello,

Rick Frankel r...@rickster.com writes:

 In the new exporter, when the option to export only the subtree is
 specified, the first heading in the subtree is used as the title of
 the document. This seems wrong, as it becomes the title, the first
 element in the table of contents and the first (not necessarily
 the top level) section in the document.

It doesn't, AFAIU. Could you explain how you do export (in particular,
where is the point when you call the export subtree process) and what do
you expect on a simple example ?

For me:

#+begin_src org
#+TITLE: title
#+OPTIONS: toc:t
* Level 1
  Body 1 X
** Level 2
   Body 2
*** Level 3
Body 3
#+end_src

with point at X will have Level 1 as its title, but Level 1 will
appear neither in the table of contents nor as the first section of the
produced document.


Regards,

-- 
Nicolas Goaziou

[O] Bug (?) in new exporter (export subtree)

2013-01-15 Thread Rick Frankel 
In the new exporter, when the option to export only the subtree is
specified, the first heading in the subtree is used as the title of
the document. This seems wrong, as it becomes the title, the first
element in the table of contents and the first (not necessarily
the top level) section in the document.

When the document is explicitly narrowed to the subtree, or the
subtree is the selected region, the #+Title: attribute is used for the
document title, which seems to be better.

Arguably, using the subtree heading for the title would be the most
logical solution when exporting a subtree -- in my case that would
usually DWIM.

rick