[O] Inconsistent output when logging things between org-indent-mode set to on and off
Hello again! I've found an inconsistency in org depending on if org-indent-mode is activated or not. When org-indent-mode is inactive i get spaces in front of schedules and deadlines under a headline, to match the start of the text of the headline i presume. When org-indent-mode is active I do not see this behaviour. Example when scheduling something with org-indent-mode on and then looking at the plain text: * Test SCHEDULED: 2011-12-23 Fri Example when scheduling something without org-indent-mode and then looking at the plain text: * Test SCHEDULED: 2011-12-23 Fri I propose is to remove the whitespace when org-indent-mode is inactive while scheduling things. Or make it a custom setting (maybe it already is?) with the default to not add whitespace. I do realize that this is a minor (really minor...) inconsistency, but it bugged me and why not report it then? Regards Gustav
Re: [O] Inconsistent output when logging things between org-indent-mode set to on and off
Hello, Gustav Wikström gustav.e...@gmail.com writes: When org-indent-mode is inactive i get spaces in front of schedules and deadlines under a headline, to match the start of the text of the headline i presume. When org-indent-mode is active I do not see this behaviour. Example when scheduling something with org-indent-mode on and then looking at the plain text: * Test SCHEDULED: 2011-12-23 Fri I don't have that behaviour. C-c C-s on an headline, with Org indent mode active, indent (virtually) the line like: * Test SCHEDULED: 2011-12-23 Fri How do you obtain that? Regards, -- Nicolas Goaziou
Re: [O] Inconsistent output when logging things between org-indent-mode set to on and off
Hello! 2011/12/23 Nicolas Goaziou n.goaz...@gmail.com Hello, Gustav Wikström gustav.e...@gmail.com writes: When org-indent-mode is inactive i get spaces in front of schedules and deadlines under a headline, to match the start of the text of the headline i presume. When org-indent-mode is active I do not see this behaviour. Example when scheduling something with org-indent-mode on and then looking at the plain text: * Test SCHEDULED: 2011-12-23 Fri I don't have that behaviour. C-c C-s on an headline, with Org indent mode active, indent (virtually) the line like: * Test SCHEDULED: 2011-12-23 Fri How do you obtain that? If you disable org-mode after the scheduling and just looking at the plain text you will see no indentation. This is good (according to me ;) ) Doing the same thing from the start, without org-indent-mode, gives another result. This is the inconsistency I mention. Kind regards Gustav
Re: [O] Inconsistent output when logging things between org-indent-mode set to on and off
Gustav Wikström gustav.e...@gmail.com writes: If you disable org-mode after the scheduling and just looking at the plain text you will see no indentation. This is good (according to me ;) ) Doing the same thing from the start, without org-indent-mode, gives another result. This is the inconsistency I mention. So, if I get it right, you claim that virtual indentation isn't consistent with real indentation. Well, this is true, but also logical. Disabling Org mode shouldn't remove all real indentation in the buffer, should it? Regards, -- Nicolas Goaziou
Re: [O] Inconsistent output when logging things between org-indent-mode set to on and off
Gustav Wikström gustav.e...@gmail.com writes: 2011/12/23 Nicolas Goaziou n.goaz...@gmail.com Gustav Wikström gustav.e...@gmail.com writes: If you disable org-mode after the scheduling and just looking at the plain text you will see no indentation. This is good (according to me ;) ) Doing the same thing from the start, without org-indent-mode, gives another result. This is the inconsistency I mention. So, if I get it right, you claim that virtual indentation isn't consistent with real indentation. Well, this is true, but also logical. Disabling Org mode shouldn't remove all real indentation in the buffer, should it? I don't see why there is real indentation at all. org-indent-mode should not change the behavior of writing content in a file. It should (imho) just add virtual indentation to make the presentation better. Either org-mode with org-indent-mode adds (non-virtual) space when calling C-c C-s (or other similar function that has this behavior) or org-mode without org-indent-mode stops adding space when calling these functions. My opinion is that there should be no space in either setting as default. You may want to have a look at both `org-adapt-indentation' and `org-indent-mode-turns-off-org-adapt-indentation' variables. Regards, -- Nicolas Goaziou
Re: [O] Inconsistent output when logging things between org-indent-mode set to on and off
You may want to have a look at both `org-adapt-indentation' and `org-indent-mode-turns-off-org-adapt-indentation' variables. Ahh, I'll look into them. Would be nice if they defaulted to the same behavior but being able to customize it solves the problem for me at least. =) Kind regards and Merry Christmas Gustav
Re: [O] Inconsistent output when logging things between org-indent-mode set to on and off
Gustav Wikström gustav.e...@gmail.com writes: Ahh, I'll look into them. Would be nice if they defaulted to the same behavior but being able to customize it solves the problem for me at least. =) The default behavior is to turn off `org-adapt-indentation' when `org-indent-mode' is turned on -- which seems correct. Anyway, glad if you found a solution! -- Bastien
